牙髓治疗结局:被引次数最多的文献分析
该研究通过Web of Science检索1960年5月至2021年7月间关于非手术根管治疗、非手术根管再治疗和根管外科结局的英文文献,按被引次数排序并计算引文密度。
要点
- 非手术根管治疗实验研究中18.55%(41/221)被引≥100次,综述中25%(9/36)。
- 根管外科实验研究12.2%(11/90)被引≥100次,综述仅6.9%(2/29)。
核心结论
- 文献计量分析有助于评估牙髓治疗结局研究对牙髓病学领域的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 通过Web of Science平台检索1960年5月至2021年7月发表的英文文献,覆盖非手术根管治疗、非手术根管再治疗和根管外科结局相关关键词。
- 文献分为非手术根管治疗、非手术根管再治疗和根管外科三组,每组再分实验研究和综述研究,按被引次数降序排列,仅纳入被引≥100次的文献,并评估引文密度。
主要发现
- 非手术根管治疗共257篇引用文献,其中实验研究221篇(86%),综述36篇(14%);实验研究中41篇(18.55%)被引≥100次,综述中9篇(25%)被引≥100次。
- 非手术根管再治疗共61篇引用文献,其中实验研究51篇(83.6%),综述10篇(16.4%);实验研究中5篇(9.8%)被引≥100次,综述中2篇(20%)被引≥100次。
- 根管外科共119篇引用文献,其中实验研究90篇(75.6%),综述29篇(24.4%);实验研究中11篇(12.2%)被引≥100次,综述中2篇(6.9%)被引≥100次。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Bibliographic analysis using quantitative measurements such as citation number and citation density is a common method used to evaluate the impact of previously published studies on current research. Several bibliographic endodontic studies ranking publications based on their number of citations have been published. However, to date, a focus on the most cited articles related to the outcome of endodontic treatment is lacking. The purpose of this study was to identify the most cited publications and their citation density as related to the outcome of nonsurgical root canal treatment (NSRCT), nonsurgical root canal retreatment (NSRCR), and root canal surgery (RCS). METHODS: A search of all citations regarding the outcome of NSRCT, NSRCR, and RCS was performed using the Web of Science platform. The search included key words covering all relevant categories. Only publications in the English language published between May 1960 and July 2021 were included. The publications were divided into the following groups: NSRCT, NSRCR, and RCS. Each group was further subdivided into experimentation studies and review studies. The publications were analyzed and sorted in descending order according to the number of citations that each publication has received. Only publications with 100 citations or more were included. Citation density was also assessed. RESULTS: The total number of NSRCT citations found was 257; 221 (86%) were experimentation studies, and 36 (14%) were review studies. Of the 221 NSRCT experimentation studies, 41 (18.55%) had 100 citations or more. Of the 36 NSRCT review studies, 9 (25%) had 100 citations or more. The total number of NSRCR citations found was 61; 51 (83.6%) were experimentation studies, and 10 (16.4%) were review studies. Of the 51 NSRCR experimentation studies, 5 (9.8%) had 100 citations or more. Of the 10 NSRCR review studies, 2 (20%) had 100 citations or more. The total number of RCS citations found was 119; 90 (75.6%) were experimentation studies, and 29 (24.4%) were review studies. Of the 90 RCS experimentation studies, 11 (12.2%) had 100 citations or more. Of the 29 RCS review studies, 2 (6.9%) had 100 citations or more. In total, 70 publications on the outcome of endodontic treatment had 100 or more citations. Fifty publications (71.4%) pertained to the NSRCT groups, 7 publications (10%) to the NSRCR groups, and 13 publications (18.6%) to the RCS groups. CONCLUSIONS: Bibliographic analysis is a beneficial aid for assessing the impact of publications studying the outcome of endodontic treatment on the field of endodontics.
引用
- Dadresanfar B, Rotstein I. Outcome of Endodontic Treatment: The Most Cited Publications. J Endod. 2021. PMID: 34562500. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2021.09.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。