指南与共识牙体牙髓病

欧洲牙髓病学会S3级指南:牙髓炎与根尖周炎疗效结局指标共识

Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of endodontic treatment for pulpitis and apical periodontitis for use in the development of European Society of Endodontology S3-level clinical practice guidelines: A consensus-based development.
指南 / 共识 · Int Endod J · 2021-09-22

欧洲牙髓病学会(ESE)为制定S3级临床实践指南,通过文献检索和改良Delphi共识法(43名指南制定组成员)确定牙髓炎和根尖周炎治疗疗效的结局指标及随访时间。患者报告结局「牙齿存活」被列为所有工作组的最关键指标,疼痛、用药需求、影像学评估等为关键指标,随访至少1年。

要点

  • 牙齿存活是牙髓炎和根尖周炎治疗疗效的最关键结局指标。
  • 疼痛、用药需求和影像学评估被列为关键结局指标。
  • 所有结局指标最低随访时间为1年,疼痛等症状可接受更短随访。

核心结论

  • 牙齿存活被指南制定组共识确定为「最关键」的患者报告结局指标。
  • 确定的结局指标和随访时间将用于委托的系统评价,以支持ESE S3级指南制定。

研究设计与样本

  • 指南制定组(GDG)43名成员通过两轮在线Delphi调查,使用9点Likert量表对结局指标重要性进行排序。
  • 文献检索后由四个工作组分别确定牙髓炎、根尖周炎非手术、手术和再生治疗的相关结局指标。

主要发现

  • 牙齿存活在四个工作组中均被评为「最关键指标」。
  • 疼痛和用药需求被视为「关键」患者报告结局,影像学评估为「关键」临床医生报告结局。
  • 需进一步干预和口腔健康相关生活质量被纳入为「重要」而非「关键」指标。
  • 工作组间存在差异:牙髓活力测试在牙髓炎组为关键,根长和宽度增加在再生治疗组为关键。

关键数值与推荐

  • 纳入标准:超过70%成员评7-9分(关键重要)且少于30%评1-3分(有限重要)的条目。
  • 排除标准:超过70%成员评1-3分且少于30%评7-9分的条目。
  • 所有结局指标最低随访1年,最长「尽可能长」,但疼痛、肿胀、用药和口腔健康相关生活质量可接受更短随访。

临床怎么用

  • 临床评估牙髓炎和根尖周炎治疗疗效时,应将牙齿存活作为首要结局指标。
  • 随访时间至少1年,疼痛等症状可在更短时间评估。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: The European Society of Endodontology (ESE) is in the process of developing S3-level clinical practice guidelines for the treatment of pulpal and apical disease. In order to support robust systematic literature reviews, appropriate outcome measures (OMs) with minimum follow-up times must first be identified. Hence, the current project aimed to identify the appropriate OMs with minimum/maximum follow-up time to assess the effectiveness of endodontic treatment for pulpitis and apical periodontitis for use in the development of ESE S3-level guidelines through a standard consensus-based methodology. METHODOLOGY: After a literature search, lists of relevant OMs were identified by the guideline development group (GDG) for the treatment of pulpitis (working group [WG] 1), the non-surgical treatment of apical periodontitis (WG 2), the surgical treatment of apical periodontitis (WG 3) and the regenerative treatment of apical periodontitis (WG 4). OMs relevant to each WG were ranked by the 43 members of the GDG in their importance to the patient using a 9-point Likert scale. Items with a score of 7-9 (critical importance) by more than 70% and items with a score of 1-3 (limited importance) by less than 30% of members were included, whereas the items with a score of 1-3 by more than 70% and items with a score of 7-9 by less than 30% were excluded. Several online Delphi meetings established an edited list of only important OMs. The ranked OMs were discussed by the GDG and harmonized to produce 'most critical', 'critical' and 'important' measures. After establishing the final ranked measures, the minimum and maximum length of follow-up related to each OM was defined by the guideline steering group. RESULTS: The Delphi survey took place over two rounds. The patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) 'tooth survival' was rated the 'most critical measure' in all four WGs, while other PROMs including 'pain' and 'need for medication' were considered 'critical', alongside the clinician-reported outcome measures (CROM), 'radiographic assessment'. The PROMs 'The need for further intervention' and 'oral-health-related-quality-of-life' (OHRQoL) were included, but as 'important' not 'critical' measures. Differences occurred between WGs with 'vitality testing' defined as critical in WG1 and 'increased length and width of the root' defined as 'critical' in WG4. A minimum of 1-year and maximum of 'as long as possible' for all OMs were deemed necessary, except 'pain', 'swelling', 'medication' and 'OHRQoL', where shorter follow-up was accepted. CONCLUSIONS: The GDG consensus process established the PROM "tooth survival" as the "most-critical". The identified OMs and length of follow-up will be applied to all the commissioned systematic reviews that will inform the subsequent process when developing the ESE S3-level clinical practice guidelines.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Duncan HF, Nagendrababu V, El-Karim I, et al. Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of endodontic treatment for pulpitis and apical periodontitis for use in the development of European Society of Endodontology S3-level clinical practice guidelines: A consensus-based development. Int Endod J. 2021. PMID: 34553383. doi:10.1111/iej.13627

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。