三种数字化工作流程制作氧化锆种植固定桥的时间效率与成本分析:双盲随机对照试验
结果显示Test-1总工作时间最短、技术成本最低,Test-2时间最长,各流程间差异均有统计学意义。全数字化流程可减少步骤、降低成本,但数字化流程并非均优于模拟流程。
要点
- 全数字化流程(口内扫描、无模型制作)总工作时间与成本均低于混合流程。
- 不同数字化流程间效率与成本差异显著,选择需考虑具体系统。
- 减少工作步骤可降低制作成本,但数字化流程不必然优于模拟流程。
核心结论
- Test-1在时间效率上表现最佳,Test-2最差,表明不同数字化流程并不相同且未必优于模拟流程。
- 完整数字化流程通过减少步骤可降低制作成本,优于常规印模加模型数字化的混合流程。
研究设计与样本
- 三种流程(Test-1:TRIOS 3/3Shape;Test-2:Virtuo Vivo/Dental Wings;对照:Impregum/3M Espe)的印模顺序随机分配。
- 记录临床与技术工作步骤,评估时间效率并进行成本分析(瑞士法郎),采用方差分析,显著性水平α=0.05。
主要发现
- 平均总工作时间(临床加技术步骤):Test-1为97.5分钟(SD±23.6),Test-2为193.1分钟(SD±25.2),对照为172.6分钟(SD±27.4)。
- 总工作时间在Test-1与Test-2间(p<0.00001)、Test-1与对照间(p<0.00001)、Test-2与对照间(p<0.03610)差异显著。
- 技术成本:Test-1为566瑞士法郎(SD±49.3),Test-2为711瑞士法郎(SD±78.8),对照为812瑞士法郎(SD±89.6),所有两两比较差异显著(p<0.00001)。
临床怎么用
- 对于三单位氧化锆种植固定桥,可优先考虑口内扫描无模型的全数字化流程以提高时间效率并降低成本。
- 不同数字化系统效率与成本差异明显,临床选择应基于具体流程的性能数据。
- 不应默认数字化流程必然优于模拟流程,需结合步骤复杂度综合评估。
局限性
- 仅评估了特定品牌系统与三单位种植固定桥,其他修复类型或系统未必适用。
- 成本分析仅涵盖技术成本,未报告其他经济指标。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This double-blinded randomized controlled trial investigated economic performance indicators (EPI) in terms of time-efficiency and production costs of 3-unit monolithic zirconium-dioxide (ZrO2) implant fixed dental prostheses (iFDP) in three different workflows. METHODS: Twenty patients with two Straumann Tissue-Level-Implants received three iFDPs; two were fabricated in proprietary complete digital workflows with intraoral optical scanning and model-free fabrication with company-related CAD/CAM lab-software while one iFDP was manufactured on digitized casts from conventional impressions. The sequence of impression-taking for the three workflows (TRIOS 3/3Shape [Test-1]; Virtuo Vivo/Dental Wings [Test-2]; Impregum/3M Espe [Control]) was randomly allocated. Sixty iFDPs bonded to ti-base abutments were analyzed. Clinical and technical worksteps for Test-1/Test-2/Control were recorded and evaluated for time-efficiency including cost-analysis (CHF=Swiss Francs) using ANOVA-Tests (significance level α=0.05). RESULTS: Mean total work time, as the sum of clinical plus technical steps, was 97.5 min (SD ± 23.6) for Test-1, 193.1 min (SD ± 25.2) for Test-2, and 172.6 min (SD ± 27.4) for Control. Times were significantly different between Test-1/Test-2 (p < 0.00001), Test-1/Control (p < 0.00001), and Test-2/Control (p < 0.03610). Technical costs were 566 CHF (SD ± 49.3) for Test-1, 711 CHF (SD ± 78.8) for Test-2, 812 CHF (SD ± 89.6) for Control, and were also significantly different for all comparisons (p < 0.00001). CONCLUSIONS: Test-1 demonstrated the best performance for time-efficiency, Test-2 revealed the worst result. This indicates that digital workflows are not the same and not necessarily superior to analog workflows of monolithic ZrO2 iFDPs. Complexity decreases by reducing the number of steps following complete digital workflows, resulting in lower production costs compared to the mixed analog-digital workflow with conventional impressions. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Complete digital workflows comprising intraoral optical scanning without physical models for treatment with monolithic ZrO2 iFDPs is an efficient alternative to mixed analog-digital workflows with conventional impressions and labside digitization of dental casts.
引用
- Joda T, Gintaute A, Brägger U, et al. Time-efficiency and cost-analysis comparing three digital workflows for treatment with monolithic zirconia implant fixed dental prostheses: A double-blinded RCT. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34391875. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103779
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。