公共牙科服务中根管治疗关键操作依从性随奖励制度而异
该回顾性研究以牙为单位,分析2016年547颗非手术初次根管治疗(RCT),比较«薪酬制»与«按服务收费»下通科牙医对4项关键操作的依从性。薪酬制牙医在橡皮障使用(43.9% vs 9.9%)、工作长度测量(85.2% vs 57.4%)及4项全达标(29.5% vs 5.8%)上均显著高于按服务收费者(P < .001)。
要点
- 薪酬制牙医的根管治疗关键操作依从性显著高于按服务收费牙医。
- 橡皮障总体使用率仅28.9%,按服务收费组更低至9.9%。
- 全部4项关键操作达标的根管治疗仅占19.0%。
核心结论
- 公共牙科服务中根管治疗存在操作缺陷,橡皮障使用不足尤为突出,需进一步研究不依从指南的原因。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性设计,以牙为观察单位,纳入2016年完成的547颗非手术初次根管治疗。
- 比较«薪酬制»(305颗牙)与«按服务收费»(242颗牙)两种牙医奖励制度下的临床操作。
- 通过电子病历和X线片评估4项关键操作:术前术后X线片、橡皮障使用、工作长度测量。
主要发现
- 术前X线片可诊断比例为76.1%,术后X线片可诊断比例为95.1%。
- 橡皮障使用记录率为28.9%,薪酬制高于按服务收费(43.9% vs 9.9%,P < .001)。
- 工作长度测量记录率为72.9%,薪酬制高于按服务收费(85.2% vs 57.4%,P < .001)。
- 4项关键操作全部达标率为19.0%,薪酬制高于按服务收费(29.5% vs 5.8%,P < .001)。
临床怎么用
- 关注按服务收费模式下根管治疗关键操作的依从性,尤其橡皮障使用。
- 可针对低依从性操作开展培训或流程改进。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: To assess clinical practices in root canal treatments (RCTs) performed by general dental practitioners under 2 different reward schemes applied in public dental services. METHODS: This study used a retrospective design with tooth as the observation unit. The data included all teeth (n = 547) with nonsurgical primary RCT completed in 2016. Electronic documents included treatment details and radiographs. RCT assessment covered 4 key items: taking pre- and postoperative radiographs, using a rubber dam, measuring working length. Assessed dichotomies indicated whether practices were adequate. Dentists' reward schemes were "salaried" and "fee-for-service." Chi squared tests analyzed frequency differences. RESULTS: RCTs formed 2 groups by the reward scheme: 305 RCTs were performed by salaried dentists and 242 by fee-for-service dentists. Preoperative radiographs were diagnosable for 76.1% and postoperative radiographs, for 95.1% of all RCTs. Rubber dam use was documented for 28.9% of the RCTs, more frequently when performed by salaried than by fee-for-service dentists (43.9% vs 9.9%, P < .001). Working length measurement was documented for 72.9% of the RCTs, more frequently for RCTs performed by salaried than by fee-for-service dentists (85.2% vs 57.4%, P < .001). All 4 key items were assessed as adequate in 19.0% of all RCTs, more frequently when performed by salaried than by fee-for-service dentists (29.5% vs 5.8%, P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Deficiencies in RCTs, particularly underuse of rubber dams call for further research to understand the reasons for noncompliance with good clinical practice guidelines.
引用
- Leinonen S, Vehkalahti MM. Compliance with Key Practices of Root Canal Treatment Varies by the Reward System Applied in Public Dental Services. J Endod. 2021. PMID: 34343591. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2021.07.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。