新冠疫情期间口腔诊疗:专家意见随访调查
该调查对27名欧洲口腔颌面外科专家进行匿名在线随访,26人参与,评估第二波疫情期间口腔诊疗感染防控意见变化。结果显示总体传播风险评分较第一波显著降低(p < .05),但气溶胶操作(AGP)风险仍被认为高,AGP时多数专家仍推荐最高级别PPE。
要点
- 总体传播风险评分较第一波显著降低(p < .05)。
- AGP相关风险仍被认为高,多数专家推荐最高级别PPE。
- 对员工和患者新冠检测的必要性未形成统一意见。
核心结论
- 随着口腔诊疗持续开展,传播风险评分较第一波疫情降低,但AGP仍被认为高风险,相应治疗仍建议最高级别PPE。
主要发现
- 总体传播风险评分较初次调查显著降低(p < .05)。
- AGP相关风险仍被认为高。
- 非AGP时推荐最高级别PPE的比例下降(p < .05)。
- AGP时多数专家仍推荐FFP2/FFP3口罩(80.8%)、面罩或护目镜(88.5%)、隔离衣(61.5%)和帽子(57.7%)。
- 多数专家认为漱口水相关(73.1%),并报告治疗前使用(76.9%)。
关键数值与推荐
- AGP时推荐FFP2/FFP3口罩(80.8%)、面罩或护目镜(88.5%)、隔离衣(61.5%)、帽子(57.7%)。
- 认为漱口水相关者占73.1%,治疗前使用者占76.9%。
- 对员工和患者新冠检测的必要性无统一意见。
临床怎么用
- AGP治疗时仍应推荐最高级别PPE,非AGP时可酌情降低PPE级别。
- 可考虑治疗前使用漱口水,但专家对新冠检测必要性未达成共识。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of the present survey is to give an update of European experts' opinion on infection control and prevention in dentistry during second wave of pandemic. The secondary aim was to analyze how experts' opinion changed in the light of the new scientific evidence since the first wave. MATERIAL & METHODS: An anonymous online 14-item questionnaire was sent to a total of 27 leading academic experts in Oral (and Maxillofacial) Surgery from different European countries, who had completed a previous survey in April-May 2020. The questionnaire covered the topics of dental setting safety, personal protective equipment (PPE), and patient-related measures to minimize transmission risk. Data collection took place in November-February 2020/21. RESULTS: 26 experts participated in the follow-up survey. The overall transmission risk in dental settings was scored significantly lower compared to the initial survey (p < .05), though the risk associated with aerosol-generating procedures (AGP) was still considered to be high. Maximum PPE was less frequently recommended for non-AGP (p < .05), whereas the majority of experts still recommended FFP2/FFP3 masks (80.8%), face shields or goggles (88.5%), gowns (61.5%), and caps (57.7%) for AGP. Most of the experts also found mouth rinse relevant (73.1%) and reported to be using it prior to treatment (76.9%). No uniform opinion was found regarding the relevance of COVID-19 testing of staff and patients. CONCLUSION: With the continuation of dental care provision, transmission risk has been scored lower compared to the first wave of pandemic. However, high risk is still assumed for AGP, and maximum PPE remained advised for the respective treatments.
引用
- Brunello G, Gurzawska-Comis K, Becker K, et al. Dental care during COVID-19 pandemic: Follow-up survey of experts' opinion. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2021. PMID: 34196051. doi:10.1111/clr.13783
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。