主观龋齿风险评估工具预测效度验证
本研究回顾性分析57,675名退伍军人,评估美国牙科协会龋齿风险评估工具在电子牙科记录中的预测效度。
要点
- 主观龋齿风险评估工具对低风险患者识别较好,但敏感性低,难以精准定位高风险患者。
- 该工具特异性尚可(0.53-0.78),阴性预测值(0.72-0.79)优于阳性预测值(0.28-0.34)。
核心结论
- 该主观龋齿风险评估工具更擅长识别未来无需龋相关治疗的低风险患者,而非高风险患者,难以针对性实施预防措施。
研究设计与样本
- 分析性流行病学研究,采用回顾性纵向设计,纳入至少三年可用数据的退伍军人,样本量57,675人。
主要发现
- 敏感性较差(0.34-0.58),特异性较好(0.53-0.78);阴性预测值(0.72-0.79)优于阳性预测值(0.28-0.34)。
- 调整逻辑回归模型显示,评估时存在的已治疗龋齿与未来龋相关治疗的关联强于主观风险评估分类。
关键数值与推荐
- 敏感性范围0.34-0.58,特异性范围0.53-0.78,阴性预测值0.72-0.79,阳性预测值0.28-0.34。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应重视评估时已存在的龋齿治疗需求,将其作为未来龋风险的重要指标,而非仅依赖主观风险评估分类。
- 使用该工具时需了解其识别高风险患者能力有限,可能需要结合其他客观指标优化高风险患者的预防策略。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The objective was to evaluate the predictive validity of the American Dental Association's caries risk assessment (CRA) tool, adapted with permission, and used by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs dental services within their electronic dental record. METHODS: This analytic epidemiologic study with a retrospective longitudinal design included Veterans who had a minimum of three years of available data. The primary outcome was caries-related treatment during the twelve-month predictive period following the CRA category identification. RESULTS: The sample included 57,675 Veterans; 50.1% classified as low, 33.2% as moderate and 16.8% as high caries risk. During the twelve-month predictive period, both teeth/person and teeth with caries-related treatment rose sequentially from low to high CRA categories. However, poor sensitivity (0.34-0.58) and better specificity (0.53-0.78) values were observed. Similarly, better negative predictive values (0.72-0.79) compared to positive predictive values (0.28-0.34) were found. Adjusted logistic regression models showed that current treated caries (caries detected at the time of the CRA exam) was more strongly associated with future caries-related treatment than the subjective CRA determination. CONCLUSIONS: The subjective CRA tool evaluated in this study is better at identifying patients at low risk of requiring future caries-related treatment versus those at higher risk. This makes it difficult to target the most caries susceptible patients with preventive measures. Furthermore, we found that the amount of caries treatment required at the time of the CRA exam had the strongest association with caries-related treatment during the subsequent twelve-month predictive period. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The amount of caries-related treatment required at the time of the caries risk classification is the strongest predictor of future caries.
引用
- Jurasic MM, Gibson G, Orner MB, et al. Validation of a Subjective Caries Risk Assessment Tool. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 34274438. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103748
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。