第6届EAO共识会议第4组:重建体的制作、工作流程与交付——总结与共识声明
本文为2021年第6届EAO共识会议第4组的总结与共识声明,基于四篇系统综述评估全瓷种植冠临床结局、计算机辅助制造时间效果成本、计算机辅助种植规划手术时间成本及患者报告结局。共识指出全瓷种植冠3年内结局良好但证据有限,CAIPS耗时成本更高,光学印模提升患者舒适度。
要点
- 全瓷种植冠(饰面与整体)3年内结局优良,证据来自49项非随机对照试验。
- 缺乏评估减材与增材CAM制作种植模型、基台和冠的时间与效果证据。
- CAIPS全流程耗时成本更高,时间因素是成本增高的决定因素(4项RCT)。
核心结论
- 全瓷种植冠短期结局良好但证据有限,CAIPS耗时成本更高,光学印模提升舒适度。
研究设计与样本
- 由经验丰富的临床医生和内容专家组成的作者组讨论并评估四篇系统综述,形成共识。
- 四篇系统综述均按PRISMA进行,检索至少三个文献数据库并手工检索。
主要发现
- 有限证据(49项NRCT)显示饰面和整体全瓷种植冠在最长3年观察期内结局优良。
- 无证据评估减材与增材CAM制作种植模型、基台和冠的生产时间与效果。
- 有限证据(4项RCT)表明CAIPS在考虑全流程及诊断、制造和修复体插入时耗时和成本更高。
- 时间似乎是成本增高的决定性因素。
- 光学印模相比传统印模制作全瓷种植冠和短跨度FPD时患者舒适度增加(2项RCT、5项NRCT)。
临床怎么用
- 全瓷种植冠短期结局优良,但需注意证据有限并关注长期效果。
- CAIPS全流程耗时成本更高,临床决策需权衡时间与成本。
- 光学印模可优先考虑以提升患者舒适度。
局限性
- 全瓷种植冠证据仅来自49项非随机对照试验,缺乏长期数据。
- CAM制作时间与效果无证据评估。
- CAIPS证据仅来自4项RCT,结论有限。
- 系统综述在语言限制和灰色文献纳入方面存在差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To report assessments of four systematic reviews (SRs) on (i) clinical outcomes of all-ceramic implant-supported crowns (iSCs), (ii) production time, effectiveness, and costs of computer-assisted manufacturing (CAM), (iii) computer-assisted implant planning and surgery (CAIPS) time and costs, and (iv) patient-reported outcome measures (PROMS). MATERIAL AND METHODS: An author group consisting of experienced clinicians and content experts discussed and evaluated the SRs and formulated consensus on the main findings, statements, clinical recommendations, and need for future research. RESULTS: All four SRs were conducted and reported according to PRISMA and detailed comprehensive search strategies in at least three bibliometric databases and hand searching. The search strategies were deemed reproducible. Variation was noted regarding language restrictions and inclusion of grey literature, but the search comprehensiveness appeared persuasive. The SRs included bias risk assessments of the primary studies, and their study methodology impacted the interpretations of the extracted data. CONCLUSIONS: (i) There is limited evidence (49 NRCT) showing that veneered and monolithic all-ceramic iSCs have excellent outcomes observed up to 3 years. (ii) There is no evidence evaluating production time and effectiveness comparing subtractive and additive CAM of implant models, abutments and crowns. (iii) There is limited evidence (4 RCT) that CAIPS involves more time and costs when considering the entire workflow and for diagnostics, manufacturing, and insertion of the restoration. Time seems to be the decisive factor for higher costs. (iv) Patients' comfort increases when optical compared to conventional impressions are used for fabricating iSCs and short-span FPDs (2 RCT, 5 NRCT).
引用
- Jokstad A, Pjetursson BE, Mühlemann S, et al. Fabrication, workflow and delivery of reconstruction: Summary and consensus statements of group 4. The 6th EAO Consensus Conference 2021. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2021. PMID: 34145922. doi:10.1111/clr.13797
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。