牙科学生实施全导板与常规导板种植手术的随机对照试验
结果显示7项偏差参数中仅颊舌向根尖偏差和颊舌向角度偏差在常规导板组显著更大,其余5项无差异,所有种植体均符合临床指南。
要点
- 牙科学生操作时,全导板与常规导板种植在7项偏差参数中5项无显著差异。
- 全导板组颊舌向根尖偏差和颊舌向角度偏差显著小于常规导板组。
- 两组所有种植体位置均符合临床指南要求。
核心结论
- 牙科学生采用全导板与常规导板种植时,7项偏差参数中5项无显著差异。
- 全导板组的颊舌向根尖偏差和颊舌向角度偏差显著低于常规导板组。
- 两组所有种植体位置均符合临床指南。
研究设计与样本
- 随机分配至全导板组(FG,n=14)或常规导板组(CG,n=12)。
- 由牙科学生实施手术,术前CBCT中3名经验丰富的研究者两次虚拟放置理想种植体。
- 比较7项偏差参数,统计学显著性水平p<.05。
主要发现
- 颊舌向根尖偏差在全导板组与常规导板组间差异显著(p=.047),常规导板组偏差更大。
- 颊舌向角度偏差在全导板组与常规导板组间差异显著(p=.019),常规导板组偏差更大。
- 其余5项偏差参数(颊舌向冠部偏差、近远中向冠部偏差、近远中向根尖偏差、近远中向角度偏差、垂直偏差)无显著差异。
- 全导板组和常规导板组均无种植体与临床指南冲突。
临床怎么用
- 牙科学生进行简单单冠种植时,全导板在颊舌向根尖和角度控制上可能优于常规导板。
- 两种导板方式下种植体位置均能满足临床指南要求。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入简单单冠种植病例,结果不宜外推至复杂病例。
- 仅由牙科学生操作,结果不宜直接推广至经验丰富的临床医生。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare fully guided with conventionally guided implant surgery performed by dental students in terms of deviation of actual implant position from an ideal implant position. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-five patients in need of 26 straightforward implant-supported single crowns were randomly allocated to a fully guided (FG, n = 14) or a conventionally guided (CG, n = 12) implant surgery. In the preoperative CBCTs, 3 experienced investigators placed a virtual implant in the ideal position, twice, allowing deviational analysis in the facio-lingual (coronal) and mesio-distal (sagittal) planes for 7 parameters. Facio-lingual crestal deviation, facio-lingual apical deviation, facio-lingual angular deviation, mesio-distal crestal deviation, mesio-distal apical deviation, mesio-distal angular deviation, and vertical deviation between the ideal, virtually placed position and actual implant position for the FG and CG groups were compared statistically (p < .05). RESULTS: Statistically significant differences between ideal and actual implant position were only seen for the facio-lingual apical deviation (p = .047) and for the facio-lingual angular deviation (p = .019), where the CG group deviated more from the ideal position than the FG group. The 5 other examined variables did not show any significant differences, and none of the implants in the FG group and CG group were placed in conflict with the clinical guidelines. CONCLUSIONS: The present study reported no difference in 5 out of 7 deviational parameters concerning actual implant position in relation to ideal implant position between a FG and CG implant placement protocol performed by dental students. Facio-lingual angular deviation and apical deviation were lower, when a FG protocol was followed. All implants were positioned according to clinical guidelines.
引用
- Søndergaard K, Hosseini M, Storgård Jensen S, et al. Fully versus conventionally guided implant placement by dental students: A randomized controlled trial. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2021. PMID: 34166539. doi:10.1111/clr.13802
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。