自报牙周病问卷的诊断准确性:基于2017病例定义的临床验证研究
本研究将CDC/AAP自报牙周病问卷译为中文(粤语)并在408名受试者中验证,以全口牙周检查及2017世界研讨会分类为标准。问卷对识别牙周病、牙周炎及III/IV期牙周炎有中高准确性,联合年龄与吸烟对III/IV期牙周炎AUROC达0.953,但对I/II期牙周炎准确性差(AUROC 0.608)。
要点
- 自报问卷对III/IV期牙周炎识别准确性高,联合年龄与吸烟AUROC 0.953。
- 问卷对I/II期牙周炎筛查准确性差,AUROC仅0.608。
- 特定问题及组合可提升对不同牙周病例定义的区分效用。
核心结论
- CDC/AAP自报问卷可作为检测牙周炎的可行工具,联合人口学与生活方式因素有助于识别III/IV期牙周炎个体。
- 该问卷对筛查I/II期牙周炎帮助较小。
- 需要在更大社区人群中进一步验证效度。
研究设计与样本
- 翻译并验证原英文CDC/AAP自报问卷,形成中文(粤语)版本。
- 共408名受试者纳入,包括牙周健康16.2%、牙龈炎15.2%、I/II期牙周炎31.8%、III/IV期牙周炎36.8%。
- 以全口牙周检查为参照,病例定义基于2017世界研讨会牙周病分类。
- 采用多变量逻辑回归和受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUROC)分析评估问卷准确性。
主要发现
- 问卷检测I/II期牙周炎准确性差,AUROC为0.608。
- 问卷识别牙周病(牙龈炎和牙周炎)的AUROC为0.837。
- 问卷识别牙周炎的AUROC为0.803。
- 问卷识别III/IV期牙周炎的AUROC为0.870。
- 自报指标联合年龄与吸烟识别III/IV期牙周炎AUROC为0.953,敏感性95.7%,特异性89.0%。
关键数值与推荐
- 牙周健康占16.2%,牙龈炎占15.2%,I/II期牙周炎占31.8%,III/IV期牙周炎占36.8%。
- 问卷检测I/II期牙周炎AUROC 0.608。
- 问卷识别牙周病AUROC 0.837,识别牙周炎AUROC 0.803,识别III/IV期牙周炎AUROC 0.870。
- 联合年龄与吸烟识别III/IV期牙周炎AUROC 0.953,敏感性95.7%,特异性89.0%。
临床怎么用
- 可将CDC/AAP自报问卷用于牙周炎检测,尤其联合年龄与吸烟因素识别III/IV期牙周炎个体。
- 不宜单独依赖该问卷筛查I/II期牙周炎。
- 特定问题及组合可提升对不同牙周病例定义的区分能力。
局限性
- 需在更大社区人群中进一步测试效度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To clinically validate a self-reported questionnaire for periodontal disease and assess its accuracy for differentiating periodontal health and different stages of periodontitis. METHODS: A Chinese (Cantonese) version of a self-reported questionnaire was prepared by translating and validating the original English questions proposed by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/American Academy of Periodontology (CDC/AAP). The utility of the CDC/AAP questionnaire and its individual questions was assessed against a full-mouth periodontal examination. Periodontal case definition was based on the 2017 World Workshop classification of periodontal diseases. Multivariable logistic regression and the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) analysis were performed to assess the accuracy of the questionnaire. RESULTS: 408 subjects enrolled in this study, including those with periodontal health (16.2%), gingivitis (15.2%), Stages I/II periodontitis (31.8%) and Stages III/IV periodontitis (36.8%). Overall, the questionnaire had poor accuracy in detecting the presence of Stages I/II periodontitis with an AUROC 0.608. While it showed moderate to high accuracy for identifying periodontal disease (gingivitis and periodontitis), periodontitis and Stages III/IV periodontitis with an AUROC of 0.837, 0.803 and 0.870, respectively. Self-reported measures in combination with age and tobacco smoking showed excellent performance for identifying Stages III/IV periodontitis with a high AUROC of 0.953, a sensitivity of 95.7%, and a specificity of 89.0%. Specific questions and combinations provided greater utility to discriminate the various periodontal case definitions. CONCLUSIONS: The self-reported CDC/AAP questionnaire may be a feasible tool for detecting periodontitis, and its combination with demographic and lifestyle factors is useful for the identification of individuals with Stages III/IV periodontitis. This questionnaire seems less helpful in screening of Stages I/II periodontitis. Further studies are needed to test the validity in larger community-based populations.
引用
- Deng K, Pelekos G, Jin L, et al. Diagnostic accuracy of self-reported measures of periodontal disease: A clinical validation study using the 2017 case definitions. J Clin Periodontol. 2021. PMID: 33998009. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13484
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。