文献速递牙体牙髓病儿童口腔

龋齿风险评估模型预测性能的系统评价与Meta分析

Assessment of predictive performance of caries risk assessment models based on a systematic review and meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2021-05-10

该系统评价与Meta分析纳入22项外部验证研究,评估7种龋齿风险评估(CRA)模型对个体龋齿增量预测的区分度和校准度。完整Cariogram的合并AUC为0.78(95%CI:0.68;0.85),简化Cariogram为0.72(95%CI:0.67;0.77),两者预测性能均可接受,简化版负担更小。其他CRA模型因高质量研究不足无法定论。

要点

  • 完整Cariogram合并AUC为0.78,简化Cariogram为0.72,预测性能均可接受。
  • 简化Cariogram较完整版预测性能更好且耗时资源更少,更值得推荐。
  • 其他CRA模型因高质量研究不足,尚无法得出确结论。

核心结论

  • 完整和简化Cariogram的平均预测性能似乎均可接受。
  • 其他纳入的CRA模型因高质量研究不足,无法对其性能得出确结论。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统评价与Meta分析,纳入22项外部验证研究,涉及7种不同的CRA模型。
  • 检索PubMed、EMBASE和CINAHL(2020年9月10日),以区分度和校准度为结局参数。
  • 使用PROBAST评估纳入研究的偏倚风险。

主要发现

  • 完整Cariogram合并AUC为0.78(95%CI:0.68;0.85,基于8项研究,不考虑偏倚风险),低偏倚风险4项研究为0.82(95%CI:0.58;0.93)。
  • 完整Cariogram合并O:E比为0.91(95%CI:0.72;1.14,基于12项研究),低偏倚风险5项研究为0.89(95%CI:0.71;1.12)。
  • 简化Cariogram合并AUC为0.72(95%CI:0.67;0.77,基于6项研究),低偏倚风险2项研究为0.74(95%CI:0.45;0.91)。
  • 简化Cariogram合并O:E比为0.84(95%CI:0.59;1.18,基于6项研究),低偏倚风险2项研究为1.05(95%CI:0.43;2.59)。
  • 其他CRA模型因研究数量不足,合并AUC范围为0.50至0.88,合并O:E比范围为0.38至1.00。

关键数值与推荐

  • 完整Cariogram合并AUC为0.78(95%CI:0.68;0.85),简化Cariogram为0.72(95%CI:0.67;0.77)。
  • 完整Cariogram合并O:E比为0.91(95%CI:0.72;1.14),简化Cariogram为0.84(95%CI:0.59;1.18)。

临床怎么用

  • 完整和简化Cariogram均可用于临床实践和社区人群中个体龋齿增量的预测。
  • 简化Cariogram较完整版预测性能更好且时间资源负担更小,可优先推荐使用。

局限性

  • 其他CRA模型因高质量研究数量不足,无法得出确结论。
  • 部分模型低偏倚风险研究数量少,合并结果置信区间较宽。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To assess the predictive performance of caries risk assessment (CRA) models for prediction of caries increment for individuals based on a systematic review and meta-analyses. DATA/SOURCES: We included external validation studies assessing the predictive performance of CRA models for prediction of caries increment for individuals, using discrimination and calibration as the outcome parameters. PubMed, EMBASE, and CINAHL were searched electronically on 10th September 2020 to identify prediction modeling studies on external validation of CRA models. The risk of bias of the included studies was assessed using the Prediction model Risk Of Bias ASsessment Tool (PROBAST). STUDY SELECTION: A total of 22 studies with seven different CRA models were included. As for full Cariogram, the pooled area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was 0.78 (95 %CI: 0.68; 0.85) based on eight studies regardless of the risk of bias levels, and 0.82 (95 %CI: 0.58; 0.93) based on four studies with low risk of bias only. The pooled observed: expected ratio (O:E ratio) of full Cariogram was 0.91 (95 %CI: 0.72; 1.14) based on 12 studies regardless of the risk of bias levels, and 0.89 (95 %CI: 0.71; 1.12) based on five studies with low risk of bias only. As for reduced Cariogram, the pooled AUC was 0.72 (95 %CI: 0.67; 0.77) based on six studies regardless of the risk of bias levels, and 0.74 (95 %CI: 0.45; 0.91) based on two studies with low risk of bias only. The pooled O:E ratio of reduced Cariogram was 0.84 (95 %CI: 0.59; 1.18) based on six studies regardless of the risk of bias levels, and 1.05 (95 %CI: 0.43; 2.59) based on two studies with low risk of bias only. Based on an insufficient number of studies for the other CRA models, the pooled AUCs ranged from 0.50 to 0.88, while the pooled O:E ratio ranged from 0.38 to 1.00. CONCLUSION: The average predictive performance of both full and reduced Cariogram seems to be acceptable. However, the evidence from research does not allow a firm conclusion on the performance of the other included CRA models, due to the insufficient number of high-quality studies. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Both full and reduced Cariogram were found to be reliable CRA models for prediction of caries increment in clinical practices for dental patients and communities for general populations. The reduced Cariogram showed better predictive performance and less burden in terms of time and resources to individuals than the full Cariogram. Therefore, the reduced Cariogram could be more recommended than the full Cariogram.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Su N, Lagerweij MD, van der Heijden GJMG, et al. Assessment of predictive performance of caries risk assessment models based on a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 33984413. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103664

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。