动态导航引导根管治疗的精度与潜在应用:一项实验室研究
该实验室研究在3D打印颌骨模型上评估动态导航系统(Navident)引导严重根管钙化(PCO)患牙开髓的3D精度与结果。三名不同经验水平的术者共预备168个开髓洞型,总体成功定位根管率为93%,根尖点平均偏差0.63 mm,平均角度偏差2.81°。结论认为动态导航精度较高,但存在学习曲线,临床使用前需大量培训。
要点
- 动态导航引导严重钙化根管开髓的总体成功率为93%,不同经验术者间无差异。
- 根尖点平均偏差0.63 mm,前牙显著低于磨牙;平均角度偏差2.81°。
- 该技术存在学习曲线,临床使用前需大量培训。
核心结论
- 动态导航是处理严重钙化根管的精确方法,但该技术存在学习曲线且临床使用前需大量培训。
研究设计与样本
- 实验室研究,在3D打印上下颌颌骨模型上由三名不同经验水平的牙体牙髓科术者使用Navident系统进行导航开髓。
- 每名术者训练28个洞型后,共预备132颗牙的168个开髓洞型(每名术者56个)。
- 术后拍摄高分辨率CBCT并与术前模型配准,用3-Matic Medical软件15.0分割开髓洞型,测量与虚拟计划的偏差。
主要发现
- 所有术者共定位156个根管,总体成功率为93%,术者经验间无差异(p > .05)。
- 根尖点平均偏差为0.63 mm(SD 0.35),前牙显著低于磨牙(p < .05)。
- 与计划相比的平均角度偏差为2.81°(SD 1.53)。
临床怎么用
- 对于严重钙化根管,动态导航可作为一种精确的开髓辅助手段。
- 临床开展前需对术者进行充分培训以克服学习曲线。
局限性
- 研究为实验室3D打印颌骨模型研究,非临床体内研究。
- 结果可能受模型与 phantom 设置影响,外推至真实临床需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate 3D accuracy and outcome of a dynamic navigation method for guided root canal treatment of severe pulp canal obliteration (PCO) in 3D printed jaws. METHODOLOGY: Three operators with different levels of experience in Endodontics performed navigated access cavities, using the Navident system (ClaroNav), in two sets (maxillary and mandibular) of 3D-printed jaw models with teeth presenting severe PCO. Models were mounted on a phantom to mimic a real clinical situation. After treatment, a postoperative high resolution Cone-Beam Computer Tomography (CBCT) scan (NewTom) was taken for each model and registered to the preoperative model. All access cavities were then segmented using 3-Matic Medical software 15.0 (Materialise). Length and volume of each access cavity were measured, and a comparison was done by measuring the distance deviation in mm at the coronal entry point, apical point, vertical deviation, total deviation and angular deviation of the access cavity in comparison with the virtual planning. Additionally, all access cavities were scouted with a size 10 K-file and inspected on the CBCT to confirm that the canal was located. Descriptive statistics for each parameter were performed. Normality of the data was assessed; data were transformed if needed to make it normally distributed. One-way analysis of variance (anova) was applied to assess differences between parameters for tooth type, jaw, and operators and corrected for simultaneous hypothesis testing according to Tukey. Significance level was set at .05. RESULTS: After training with the system (28 cavities per operator), a total of 132 teeth and 168 access cavities (56 per operator) were prepared. All operators located a total of 156 canals, obtaining an overall success of 93% without a difference between operator experience (p > .05). The mean deviation at the apical point was 0.63 mm (SD 0.35) and was significantly lower in anterior teeth in comparison with molars (p < .05). The mean angular deviation from the planning was 2.81° (SD 1.53). CONCLUSION: Dynamic navigation was an accurate approach for root canal treatment in teeth with severely calcified canals. However, the technique has a learning curve and requires extensive training prior to its use clinically.
引用
- Torres A, Boelen GJ, Lambrechts P, et al. Dynamic navigation: a laboratory study on the accuracy and potential use of guided root canal treatment. Int Endod J. 2021. PMID: 33991122. doi:10.1111/iej.13563
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。