外展牙科项目中两种窝沟封闭方法的最小成本分析
本研究在外展牙科项目中对小学生第一恒磨牙采用树脂封闭剂或玻璃离子ART封闭剂预防窝沟龋,18个月后两组龋发病率无显著差异(p=0.552),最小成本分析显示ART封闭剂成本更低,是外展服务中经济性更优的替代方案。
要点
- ART封闭剂与树脂封闭剂防龋效果相当,18个月龋发病率无显著差异。
- ART封闭剂在外展牙科服务中成本低于树脂封闭剂。
- 设备/器械预期寿命是影响封闭成本的主要参数。
核心结论
- ART封闭剂是外展牙科服务中预防窝沟龋成本更低的替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 在两所随机选择的小学开展外展牙科项目,一组接受政府资助的牙科封闭服务(group 1),另一组未接受(group 2)。
- group 1的126名儿童应用445个封闭剂,group 2的203名儿童应用668个封闭剂。
- 18个月后基于两种方法的疗效结果进行最小成本分析。
主要发现
- 18个月后group 1龋发病率为29.4%,group 2为28.6%。
- Logistic回归分析显示两组间差异无统计学意义(p=0.552)。
- 分析模型显示ART封闭剂在经济上优于树脂封闭剂。
- 敏感性分析显示封闭应用中设备/器械的预期寿命是影响成本的主要参数。
临床怎么用
- 在外展牙科服务中,ART封闭剂可作为树脂封闭剂的替代方案用于窝沟龋预防。
- 对于农村等需求最大的人群,ART封闭剂可能更适用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To conduct economic evaluation of two sealing methods (placement of resin sealant or glass ionomer ART sealant) in preventing pit and fissure caries in permanent first molars (PFMs) in schoolchildren. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An outreach dental program was conducted in two randomly selected primary schools, one was covered by the national government-funded dental sealing service (group 1) and the other was not (group 2). Resin or ART sealant (sealant using glass ionomer material with the aid of the finger-press technique) was applied to all of the eligible PFMs in group 1 and group 2 students (grade 1 or 2), respectively. All the applications was provided at school. The cost for sealant application was recorded for each method. After 18 months, a cost minimisation analysis was performed based on the efficacy results of the two methods. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: In total, 445 sealants were applied to 126 children in group 1, and 668 sealants were applied to 203 children in group 2. Dental caries incidence was 29.4 % in group 1 and 28.6 % in group 2 after 18 months. Logistic regression analysis showed no statistically significant difference (p = 0.552) between the two groups. Cost minimisation analysis was used to evaluate the economic performance. The analytical model showed that the ART sealant was economically better than resin sealant. Sensitivity analysis showed that the life expectancy of the equipment/instrument used in sealant applications was the major parameter affecting the cost. The cost of using ART sealant over the study period was lower than that of using resin sealant. Overall, ART sealant is a less costly alternative for pit and fissure caries prevention in outreach dental services. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: While pit and fissure sealing using ART sealant was as effective as using resin sealant in dental caries prevention, the cost of using ART sealant was lower than that of using resin sealant. Therefore, ART sealant could be a good alternative to resin sealant for pit and fissure caries prevention in outreach dental services for rural populations who have the greatest need.
引用
- Liu B, Wang W. A cost minimisation analysis of two dental sealing methods in an outreach dental program. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 33961937. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103687
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。