根尖手术与非手术再治疗长期生存率比较
该7年回顾性研究基于1021颗牙的保险理赔数据,比较非手术再治疗与根尖手术的生存率。非手术再治疗2、4、6年生存率分别为90%、86.8%、85%,根尖手术为93.7%、90.5%、88%,两者无统计学显著差异,牙位亦非影响因素。
要点
- 非手术再治疗与根尖手术的长期生存率无显著差异。
- 牙位(前牙、前磨牙、磨牙)不影响两种治疗生存率。
- 临床可在初次根管治疗失败后选择任一种再治疗方式。
核心结论
- 初次根管治疗失败后,临床可选择非手术再治疗或根尖手术,两者长期生存率无统计学显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 7年回顾性研究,分析2008-2017年Delta Dental of Wisconsin数据库中987例患者的1021颗牙的保险理赔数据。
- 仅纳入牙髓专科医生完成的非手术再治疗或根尖手术。
主要发现
- 非手术再治疗牙2年生存率90%,4年86.8%,6年85%。
- 根尖手术牙2年生存率93.7%,4年90.5%,6年88%。
- 非手术再治疗与根尖手术生存率无统计学显著差异。
- 前牙、前磨牙、磨牙组内及组间比较均无统计学显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生可在初次根管治疗失败后根据具体情况选择非手术再治疗或根尖手术。
- 牙位不作为选择非手术再治疗或根尖手术的决定因素。
局限性
- 研究为回顾性设计,仅基于保险理赔数据。
- 仅纳入牙髓专科医生完成的治疗,结果可能不适用于全科医生。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The decision of which modality of secondary endodontic treatment to perform is multifactorial and clinician dependent. The literature surrounding the long-term survival of nonsurgical retreatment compared with surgical retreatment remains equivocal and warrants further investigation. This 7-year retrospective study seeks to compare the outcome of nonsurgical retreatments with that of root-end surgeries performed on teeth without prior nonsurgical retreatments. METHODS: Insurance claims from 1021 teeth of 987 patients in the Delta Dental of Wisconsin database were analyzed from the years 2008-2017. Tooth survival was evaluated using Cox regression models, and the P value was set at .05. Survival time was considered from the time of completion of nonsurgical retreatment or root-end surgery to the time of an untoward event, which was defined as extraction after root-end surgery or extraction/root-end surgery after nonsurgical retreatment. Only procedures performed by endodontists were included in the analysis. RESULTS: The survival rate of teeth that received nonsurgical retreatment was 90% after 2 years, 86.8% after 4 years, and 85% after 6 years. The survival rate of teeth that received root-end surgery was 93.7% after 2 years, 90.5% after 4 years, and 88% after 6 years. No statistically significant difference was found in the survival of nonsurgical retreatment compared with root-end surgery. Likewise, no statistically significant difference was found within or between tooth types (anterior, premolar, or molar) when comparing nonsurgical retreatment with root-end surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that clinicians can choose either nonsurgical retreatment or root-end surgery after failed primary root canal therapy. Tooth location was not a determining factor in the survival rate after nonsurgical retreatment or root-end surgery.
引用
- Haxhia E, Ibrahim M, Bhagavatula P, et al. Root-end Surgery or Nonsurgical Retreatment: Are There Differences in Long-term Outcome? J Endod. 2021. PMID: 33961913. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2021.04.024
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。