2006至2020年牙种植定性研究文献的批判性综述
该批判性综述系统检索2006至2020年牙种植定性研究文献,从8421条原始结果中识别出25篇使用定性方法的文章,并用CASP清单评价其质量。研究发现定性研究数量仍少,质量在近二十年有所改善,但定性数据分析存在不一致,患者与牙医对种植流程及管理的观点研究仍不足。
要点
- 牙种植领域定性研究数量仍低,近二十年质量有所改善。
- 定性研究质量存在不一致,尤其定性数据分析方面。
- 患者与牙医对种植流程和管理的观点研究仍缺乏。
核心结论
- 牙种植领域定性研究数量仍低,但质量在近二十年有所改善。
- 对患者和牙医关于牙种植流程与管理的观点研究仍缺乏。
研究设计与样本
- 对2006至2020年牙种植定性研究文章进行系统检索与批判性综述。
- 从8421条原始结果中识别出25篇使用定性方法的文章。
- 采用Critical Appraisal Skills programme(CASP)清单评价纳入文章质量。
主要发现
- 8421条原始结果中仅25篇使用定性方法。
- 研究者关注患者对缺牙、种植体及牙科专业人员所提供信息的看法。
- 研究者也关注牙医对牙种植实践的看法。
- 定性研究质量存在不一致,尤其定性数据分析方面。
临床怎么用
- 临床可关注患者对缺牙、种植体及所获信息的观点。
- 临床可关注牙医对牙种植实践的看法。
- 解读牙种植定性证据时需注意其数据分析质量可能不一致。
局限性
- 牙种植领域定性研究数量仍低。
- 对患者和牙医关于种植流程与管理的观点研究仍缺乏。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This critical review is aimed to investigate the current status of qualitative research in dental implant research and to explore the quality of available information. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A systematic search was done on the journal databases to identify dental implant research articles that used qualitative methodology during 2006 and 2020. The resulting articles were appraised against the checklist offered by the Critical Appraisal Skills programme (CASP) tool. Also, the theories evolved from the research were reviewed to understand the value of this methodology in dental implant research. RESULTS: Twenty-five (25) articles out of the 8,421 original results were identified as using qualitative methodology. The researchers have sought to identify the views of patients about tooth loss, dental implants, and the information they receive from dental professionals, and views of the dentists about dental implant practice. The review found that there were few inconsistencies in the quality of such research especially the qualitative data analysis. CONCLUSIONS: The quantity of qualitative research in dental implants remains low; however, the quality has improved in the past two decades. Despite these improvements, there is still a lack of research in understanding both patients' and dentists' views on dental implant procedures and management.
引用
- Jayachandran S, Hill K, Walmsley AD, et al. A critical review of qualitative research publications in dental implants from 2006 to 2020. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2021. PMID: 33715249. doi:10.1111/clr.13743
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。