预防性口腔护理的价值:离散选择实验
该研究采用在线离散选择实验(DCE)调查英国全国代表性普通人群对预防性口腔护理服务和结果的偏好及支付意愿(WTP),共667人完成。结果显示,受访者重视更频繁的洁治抛光(SP)、牙医提供的护理和个性化口腔卫生指导(OHA),并对减少刷牙出血和改善美观结果有支付意愿;对美观改善的支付意愿(+£145/y)高于减少出血频率(+£100/y)。
要点
- 普通人群重视常规提供的洁治抛光,即使刷牙出血未减少。
- 受访者偏好牙医提供护理和个性化口腔卫生指导。
- 对美观改善的支付意愿高于减少刷牙出血频率。
核心结论
- 普通人群重视常规提供的洁治抛光,即使没有减少刷牙出血。
- 口腔服务提供者在服务重新设计时应考虑服务使用者对健康和nonhealth结果的偏好。
- 研究提供了边际支付意愿估计,可用于这些口腔护理服务的成本效益分析。
研究设计与样本
- 在线离散选择实验(DCE),英国全国代表性普通人群样本。
- 每位受访者回答10个选择任务,任务属性包括服务属性(SP、OHA和护理提供者)、结果(牙龈出血和美观)和成本。
- 选择任务采用pivoted segmented experimental design以提高任务真实性。
- 使用误差成分面板logit模型分析数据。
- 共667名受访者完成DCE。
主要发现
- 受访者重视更频繁的SP、牙医提供的护理和个性化OHA。
- 受访者愿意为产生更少频率(「never」或「hardly ever」)刷牙出血和牙齿看起来和感觉至少「moderately clean」的口腔护理套餐付费。
- 受访者对美观结果从「very unclean」(-£85/y)改善到「very clean」(+£60/y)的支付意愿(+£145/y)高于对减少出血频率从「very often」(-£54/y)到「never」(+£36/y)的支付意愿(+£100/y)。
关键数值与推荐
- 边际支付意愿(mWTP)按属性和水平计算。
- 美观结果从「very unclean」(-£85/y)到「very clean」(+£60/y)的mWTP为+£145/y。
- 减少出血频率从「very often」(-£54/y)到「never」(+£36/y)的mWTP为+£100/y。
临床怎么用
- 口腔服务提供者在服务重新设计时应考虑服务使用者偏好,包括对健康和nonhealth结果的偏好。
- 研究提供的mWTP估计可用于这些口腔护理服务的成本效益分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Scale and polish (SP) and oral hygiene advice (OHA) are commonly provided in primary care dental practice to help prevent periodontal disease. These services are widely consumed by service users, incurring substantial cost, without any clear evidence of clinical benefit. This article aims to elicit general population preferences and willingness to pay (WTP) for preventative dental care services and outcomes. An online discrete-choice experiment (DCE) was completed by a nationally representative sample of the UK general population. Respondents each answered 10 choice tasks that varied in terms of service attributes (SP, OHA, and provider of care), outcomes (bleeding gums and aesthetics), and cost. Choice tasks were selected using a pivoted segmented experimental design to improve task realism. An error components panel logit model was used to analyze the data. Marginal WTP (mWTP) for each attribute and level was calculated. In total, 667 respondents completed the DCE. Respondents valued more frequent SP, care provided by a dentist, and personalized OHA. Respondents were willing to pay for dental packages that generated less frequent ("never" or "hardly ever") bleeding on brushing and teeth that look and feel at least "moderately clean." Respondents were willing to pay more (+£145/y) for improvements in an aesthetic outcome from "very unclean" (-£85/y) to "very clean" (+£60/y) than they were for reduced bleeding frequency (+£100/y) from "very often" (-£54/y) to "never" (+£36/y). The general population value routinely provided SP, even in the absence of reductions in bleeding on brushing. Dental care service providers must consider service user preferences, including preferences for both health and nonhealth outcomes, as a key factor in any service redesign. Furthermore, the results provide mWTP estimates that can be used in cost-benefit analysis of these dental care services.
引用
- Boyers D, van der Pol M, Watson V, et al. The Value of Preventative Dental Care: A Discrete-Choice Experiment. J Dent Res. 2021. PMID: 33541186. doi:10.1177/0022034521989943
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。