欧洲牙髓病学会S3级临床实践指南:牙髓炎与根尖周炎疗效评价结局指标方案
欧洲牙髓病学会(ESE)正在制定牙髓及根尖周疾病治疗的S3级临床实践指南。本项目采用共识流程,由指南制定组(GDG)42名成员对结局指标的重要性进行9分Likert量表评分,以确定核心临床医生报告和患者报告结局指标及最低随访时间,用于后续系统评价。建议评估牙髓炎和根尖周炎治疗效果的随访时间至少为一年。
要点
- 采用9分Likert量表由42名GDG成员对结局指标重要性评分,多数评分7-9分者定为关键指标。
- 建议评估牙髓炎和根尖周炎治疗效果的随访时间至少为一年。
- 针对疼痛、肿胀、用药或诊断准确性等特定问题的研究可采用较短随访期。
核心结论
- 通过共识流程确定牙髓治疗的核心结局指标和最低随访时间,用于ESE S3级指南的系统评价。
研究设计与样本
- 指南制定项目,设立4个工作组,由10人指导组和42人指南制定组(GDG)组成。
- 通过检索既往综述、ESE指南和立场声明编制潜在结局指标列表。
主要发现
- GDG成员将对结局变量进行9分Likert量表评分,多数评为7-9分的指标被视为关键结局指标。
关键数值与推荐
- 关键结局指标定义为多数调查参与者评为7-9分(9分Likert量表)的指标。
- 评估牙髓炎和根尖周炎治疗效果的随访时间至少考虑一年。
- 针对疼痛、肿胀、用药或诊断准确性的研究可能采用较短随访期。
临床怎么用
- 后续系统评价将采用共识确定的结局指标和随访时间,以指导ESE S3级指南制定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The European Society of Endodontology (ESE) is in the process of developing S3Level Clinical Practice Guidelines for the treatment of pulpal and apical disease for the benefit of clinicians and patients. In order to ensure a homogenous review process in the development of the clinical practice guidelines, it is essential that the core outcomes for all endodontic treatments are standardized and recommendations are made regarding minimum follow-up time specific to each outcome measure. In the absence of a recognized core outcome set in Endodontics, the current project aimed to follow an established consensus process to define the most appropriate clinician and patient-reported outcomes. As part of the project, recommendations will also be agreed regarding an acceptable minimum follow-up period for studies by literature review and group discussion. The selected outcome measures and follow-up periods will be used in subsequent systematic analyses of the literature to investigate the effectiveness of endodontic treatment to alleviate pulpitis and apical periodontitis. In this paper, previous reviews, ESE Guidelines and Position Statements were searched in order to compile a list of potentially important outcome measures for the treatment of pulpitis (working group 1), the nonsurgical treatment of apical periodontitis (working group 2), the surgical treatment of apical periodontitis (working group 3) and the regenerative treatment of apical periodontitis (working group 4). Initially, the two S3 guideline leads selected two independent senior clinical academics with experience of evidence-based dentistry to lead each of the four working groups forming a 10-member steering group. The working group leads in turn selected 32 academics with experience of evidence-based dentistry to lead the individual systematic reviews contained within the respective working groups. These 42 individuals make up the Guideline Development Group (GDG). Prior to the selected systematic reviewers commencing writing and submitting the review protocol, the complete list of outcome variables identified in this document will be ranked by the 42 members of the GDG in their importance to the individual patient using a 9-point Likert scale. A summary of the survey scores will thereafter be shared with the members of the group and the final list of clinician and patient-reported outcome measures rated as critical for decision making (7-9 on Likert scale by majority of survey participants) to guide systematic reviews will be consented and confirmed during an online meeting of the steering group. In this online meeting, another aspect with regard to meaningfulness of clinical trial results to be addressed in systematic reviews will be consented: length of follow-up. In order to develop high quality guidelines, it is suggested that the follow-up period after treatment should be related to the specific outcome measure being addressed; however, a minimum of one year for assessing the effectiveness of treatments for pulpitis and apical periodontitis should be considered. It is accepted, that selected research questions that focus on pain, swelling, medication taken or investigating diagnostic accuracy are likely to have shorter follow-up periods. As a result of the GDG consensus process, the outcome measures and length of follow-up will, alongside the use of standard instruments to assess the methodological quality of clinical trials and other comparative studies, be applied to all the commissioned systematic reviews that will inform the subsequent process when developing the ESE S3 Level Clinical Practice Guidelines.
引用
- Duncan HF, Nagendrababu V, El-Karim IA, et al. Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of endodontic treatment for pulpitis and apical periodontitis for use in the development of European Society of Endodontology (ESE) S3 level clinical practice guidelines: a protocol. Int Endod J. 2021. PMID: 33630330. doi:10.1111/iej.13501
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。