复杂根管治疗磨牙生存率与根管愈合的回顾性研究
这项基于临床实践的回顾性研究评估了接受复杂根管治疗(ETC评分II和III)的磨牙在最长89个月内的生存率和根管愈合情况。共纳入279颗磨牙进行生存分析、268颗进行根管成功分析,89个月累积生存率为91.7%,48和89个月累积根管愈合率分别为82.2%和51.1%。邻牙缺失和根管形态偏差显著降低生存率,根管形态偏差和冠部封闭不足显著降低根管愈合率。
要点
- 复杂根管治疗磨牙89个月累积生存率为91.7%(95%CI: 86.8%-94.9%)
- 邻牙缺失和根管形态偏差显著降低牙齿生存概率
- 根管形态偏差和冠部封闭不足显著降低根管愈合概率
核心结论
- 需要复杂根管治疗的磨牙在89个月时累积生存率为91.7%(95%CI: 86.8%-94.9%),生存率令人满意。
研究设计与样本
- 排除开放根尖、合并手术治疗、ETC评分I、年龄小于18岁或ASA评分大于2的患者。
- 279颗磨牙(245例患者)纳入生存分析,268颗磨牙纳入根管成功分析。
- 采用累积生存估计和Cox回归分析评估牙齿生存和根管愈合,使用FDI标准评估修复质量,α设为0.05。
主要发现
- 89个月累积生存率为91.7%(95%CI: 86.8%-94.9%)。
- 邻牙缺失和根管形态偏差显著降低牙齿生存概率。
- 48个月和89个月累积根管愈合率分别为82.2%(95%CI: 75.7%-87.1%)和51.1%(95%CI: 20.2%-75.5%)。
- 根管形态偏差和冠部封闭不足显著降低根管愈合概率。
- 间接修复体在美学和生物学FDI评分上更高,但直接与间接修复体在功能FDI评分上无差异。
临床怎么用
- 对于需要复杂根管再治疗的磨牙,临床医生可参考本研究的生存率数据与患者沟通治疗选择。
- 应关注邻牙缺失、根管形态偏差、冠部封闭不足等影响预后的因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The objective of this retrospective practice-based study was to evaluate the survival of molar teeth and endodontic success after complex endodontic treatment up to 89 months. METHODS: Endodontically (Endodontic Treatment Classification (ETC) scores II and III) treated first and second molars treated between January 2011-October 2017 within a referral setting were included. Open apices, combined surgical treatment, ETC score I, patients <18 years or with an ASA-score >2 were excluded. Cumulative survival estimates and Cox regression analysis were performed for tooth survival and endodontic healing according to the Glossary of Endodontic Terms. Restoration quality was assessed using the FDI criteria. Alpha was set at 0.05. RESULTS: 279 endodontically treated molars in 245 patients were included for survival analysis and 268 molars for endodontic success. After 89 months, the cumulative survival was 91.7 % [95 % CI: 86.8 %-94.9 %]. Absence of adjacent teeth and deviance in root canal morphology significantly decreased the probability of tooth survival. Cumulative endododontic healing rates after 48 and 89 months were 82.2 % [95 %CI: 75.7 %-87.1 %] and 51.1 [95 % CI: 20.2 %-75.5 %] respectively. Deviance in root canal morphology and inadequate coronal seal significantly decreased the probability of endodontic healing. Indirect restorations obtained higher esthetic and biological FDI scores, however no difference between direct and indirect restorations was found concerning the functional FDI score. CONCLUSIONS: After 89 months, cumulative survival of molars in need of complex endodontic treatment was 91.7 % [95 % CI: 86.8 %-94.9 %]. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Within daily clinical practice, the dilemma of performing a complex endodontic (re)treatment or to explore other treatment options for molar teeth in need of reintervention is still urgent. Tooth survival of molar teeth with complex endodontic (re)treatment seems satisfactory up to 89 months.
引用
- de Kuijper MCFM, Meisberger EW, Rijpkema AG, et al. Survival of molar teeth in need of complex endodontic treatment: Influence of the endodontic treatment and quality of the restoration. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 33617944. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2021.103611
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。