种植体软组织开裂覆盖美学评分(IDES):评分者内与评分者间一致性的初步分析
本研究提出用于评估种植体周围软组织开裂/不足(PSTD)覆盖疗效的美学指数IDES,并测试其评分者内与评分者间信度。四名牙周医生对51例单颗PSTD治疗前后的照片进行两次评分,IDES包含软组织边缘水平、种植体周围乳头高度、黏膜颜色和黏膜外观四项,总分10分。结果显示总体IDES的ICC为0.86,各单项ICC为0.78至0.87,评分者内变异可忽略,提示IDES是评估PSTD覆盖美学效果的可信工具。
要点
- IDES包含四项指标:软组织边缘水平、乳头高度、黏膜颜色和黏膜外观,总分10分。
- 总体IDES的ICC为0.86,各单项ICC为0.78至0.87,评分者间信度良好。
- 评分者内变异可忽略,IDES评分与评分者主观美学评价高度相似。
核心结论
- IDES在4名评分者中表现出稳定的判断,跨时间点的评分者内变异轻微,可作为评估PSTD覆盖美学效果的可信工具。
研究设计与样本
- 初步研究,纳入51例单颗PSTD的基线和治疗后照片,由来自3个中心的4名牙周医生在2个时间点使用IDES进行评分。
主要发现
- 总体IDES的ICC为0.86,各单项ICC范围为0.78至0.87。
- 评分者内变异可忽略,评分者间美学评价具有可重复性。
- 评分者的IDES值与主观美学反应高度相似。
关键数值与推荐
- IDES评估治疗后软组织边缘水平、种植体周围乳头高度、黏膜颜色和黏膜外观,总分10分。
临床怎么用
- IDES可用于标准化PSTD治疗后的美学评估。
局限性
- 本研究为初步分析,样本量有限,结论需在更多研究中验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To introduce an esthetic index for assessing the outcomes of peri-implant soft tissue dehiscence/deficiency (PSTD) coverage and test its within- and between-reviewer reliability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Photographs of 51 single PSTDs at baseline and after treatment were provided to four periodontists from three centers. The examiners were asked to rate each case at two timepoints with the Implant soft tissue Dehiscence/deficiency coverage Esthetic Score (IDES) that involved the evaluation of the post-treatment level of the soft tissue margin, peri-implant papillae height, mucosa color, and mucosa appearance (summing up to a total score of 10). Variance components analysis was conducted using multilevel regression fit in a Bayesian framework for obtaining uncertainty intervals for fractional variance contributions and intraclass correlation values (ICC) of the IDES, and for each of its four clinical variables. RESULTS: Regression models showed reproducible esthetic evaluation among the examiners (inter-reliability) and negligible intra-reviewer variability (assessment of the same case at different timepoints). The ICC for the variability in the assessment of the overall IDES was 0.86, and for the individual components ranged from 0.78 to 0.87. Additionally, there was a strong similarity between the raters' IDES values, and their subjective esthetic response, by the same raters. CONCLUSION: The IDES showed persistent judgment among the 4 reviewers, and only a slight intra-reviewer variability across timepoints. Within its limitations, this study suggests that the proposed novel score can be a reliable tool for evaluating the esthetic outcomes of PSTD coverage, which can aid in standardization of esthetic assessments following the treatment of a PSTD.
引用
- Zucchelli G, Barootchi S, Tavelli L, et al. Implant soft tissue Dehiscence coverage Esthetic Score (IDES): A pilot within- and between-rater analysis of consistency in objective and subjective scores. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2021. PMID: 33420729. doi:10.1111/clr.13706
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。