操作者背景影响口内扫描的期望、感知与表现
研究邀请牙医、牙科研究生和修复师学生参加口内扫描(IOS)培训,完成全牙弓扫描并填写问卷。结果显示各组对IOS期望和体验均积极,但修复师学生扫描时间显著更长,培训需求因背景而异,成本是采用IOS的主要障碍。
要点
- 不同背景操作者对IOS的期望和感知均积极,但扫描表现和培训需求因背景而异。
- 修复师学生的总扫描时间显著长于其他组,需定制化培训。
- 成本影响大多数参与者采用IOS的决策。
核心结论
- 不同背景和培训经历的操作者对IOS的期望和感知普遍积极,但扫描表现和培训需求取决于操作者背景。
- IOS成本仍是获取该技术的障碍,需调整以提高可及性。
研究设计与样本
- 邀请牙医(DENT)、牙科研究生(DPG)和修复师学生(PROS)参加IOS培训工作坊。
- 参与者完成模型上全牙弓扫描并记录总扫描时间(TST),并填写匿名培训前后问卷。
主要发现
- 93%的参与者报告对IOS有积极期望。
- 合并TST为285 ± 83秒,PROS的TST显著更长(p < 0.05,337 ± 79秒)。
- 60%的PROS和50%的DENT报告需要进一步培训,而DPG为14%。
- 96%的参与者报告积极的IOS体验,74%认为其准确,63%认为其易用。
- 85%的参与者表示成本会影响其在临床中采用IOS的决定。
临床怎么用
- IOS培训必须定制化,以满足不同操作者的需求。
- 需调整IOS成本以提高其可及性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: to assess the expectations, perceptions and performance of different operators with varying backgrounds and training in the use of full-arch intraoral scanning (IOS). METHODS AND MATERIALS: Dentists (DENT), postgraduate dental students (DPG), and student prosthetists (PROS) were invited to join an IOS training workshop. Participants completed a satisfactory scan of a mannikin-mounted typodont with the total scanning time (TST) recorded. They also completed anonymised pre and post-training questionnaires covering their background, and IOS expectations and experience. Statistical analysis was performed using the Mann-Whitney U, Kruskal Wallis, and chi-square tests. Open-ended questions were analysed manually and using Leximancer. RESULTS: Twenty-seven participants were recruited: 10 DENT; 10 PROS; and 7 DPG. Positive expectations of IOS was reported by 93 % of participants. Combined TST was 285 ± 83 s, with the PROS TST significantly longer (p < 0.05, 337 ± 79 s). Further training need was reported by 60 % of PROS and 50 % of DENT versus 14 % of DPG. Positive IOS experience was reported by 96 % of participants, 74 % perceived it to be accurate, and 63 % found it easy to use. Eighty-five percent of all participants stated that cost would influence their decision of adopting IOS in their practice. CONCLUSION: Expectations and perceptions of IOS were overwhelmingly positive, irrespective of operator background and experience. Scanning performance and training needs depended on the operator's background. Cost of IOS remains a barrier to acquiring the technology. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: IOS training must be customised to accommodate the needs of different operators. The cost of IOS needs revision to improve its accessibility.
引用
- Ahmed KE, Peres KG, Peres MA, et al. Operators matter - An assessment of the expectations, perceptions, and performance of dentists, postgraduate students, and dental prosthetist students using intraoral scanning. J Dent. 2020. PMID: 33387570. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103572
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。