文献速递牙周病

口内扫描仪记录口腔图像无创评估牙龈炎症的可行性验证研究

A proof of concept study to confirm the suitability of an intra oral scanner to record oral images for the non-invasive assessment of gingival inflammation.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2021-01-05

本研究比较了椅旁使用无创改良牙龈指数(MGI)与口内扫描(IOS)图像(10天后判读)获得的牙龈炎症评分。23名健康成人共552个牙龈位点中,90%位点评分一致,两名检查者从扫描图像判读的MGI评分一致率为91%,无超过1个等级差异。结论认为IOS图像能准确捕捉牙龈轮廓,可用于无创评估牙龈健康或炎症程度。

要点

  • IOS图像与临床MGI评分在90%的牙龈位点一致,可用于无创评估牙龈炎症。
  • 两名检查者从扫描图像判读MGI的一致率为91%,无超过1个等级的差异。
  • 最常见误差为临床0分被扫描判为1分,以及扫描3分被临床判为2分。

核心结论

  • 扫描图像获得的MGI评分与临床MGI评分非常相似,IOS能准确捕捉牙龈轮廓图像以判断健康或牙龈炎症程度。

研究设计与样本

  • 单次就诊、前牙区、观察性、概念验证研究,纳入具有不同牙龈炎症程度的健康成人参与者。
  • 共23名参与者(年龄18-72岁),提供552个牙龈位点数据。
  • 一名检查者完成临床和口内扫描MGI评估,第二名检查者从IOS重复MGI评估。

主要发现

  • 临床与IOS的MGI评分在90%的位点一致。
  • 最常见的分歧为MGI 0级被判读为1级,以及2级被判读为3级。
  • 临床0分被IOS判为1分的最高单一错误概率:检查者1为0.118,检查者2为0.129。
  • IOS 3分被临床判为2分的第二常见错误概率:检查者1为0.089,检查者2为0.097。
  • 两名检查者从扫描图像获得的MGI评分相似(一致率91%),无超过1个等级的差异;临床MGI与IOS颜色/质地评分高度一致。

临床怎么用

  • IOS图像可用于临床评估牙龈健康或炎症状态,支持远程评估和数据验证。
  • IOS在一般实践和研究中具有高效准确采集数据的潜力。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To compare gingival inflammation scores obtained chairside using the non-invasive modified gingival index (MGI) with MGI scores from an intraoral scan (IOS) captured at the clinical visit but viewed 10 days later. METHODS: Single visit, anterior teeth, observational, proof of concept study in healthy adult participants with a spectrum of gingival inflammation. One investigator performed both clinical and intraoral scan MGI assessments, a second repeated the MGI evaluation from the IOS. RESULTS: 23 participants aged 18-72 yielded data for 552 gingival sites. There was agreement at 90 % of sites comparing clinical with IOS MGI scores. The commonest disagreements were MGI grade 0 read as 1 and 2 read as 3, the highest single probability of error occurring where a clinical score of 0 was scored 1 from the IOS: 0.118 and 0.129 for examiners 1 and 2 respectively. The second most common probability of error occurred where an IOS score of 3 was scored clinically as 2: 0.089 and 0.097 for examiners 1 and 2 respectively. MGI scores from the scans were similar for both examiners (91 % agreement), with no discrepancies of greater than 1 scale point. There was very close agreement between clinical MGI and IOS colour/texture scores. CONCLUSION: This study conclusively demonstrated that the MGI score from the scanned image was very similar to the MGI scored clinically. This study confirms that a digital IOS accurately captures gingival contour images allowing a clinician to determine health or degree of gingival inflammation from it using MGI scores. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: This study confirms that IOS images of teeth and soft tissues are sufficiently accurate to allow the clinical evaluation of health or inflammatory gingival status using non-invasive indices. IOS has great potential for efficient and accurate data capture, for general practice and research facilitating remote evaluation and data verification.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Daly S, Seong J, Parkinson C, et al. A proof of concept study to confirm the suitability of an intra oral scanner to record oral images for the non-invasive assessment of gingival inflammation. J Dent. 2021. PMID: 33417977. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103579

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。