声门塞音对腭裂术后鼻音计评价腭咽闭合的影响
纳入71例腭裂术后语音障碍患者,用鼻音计和鼻咽纤维内镜同步评估,按有无声门塞音分组比较11个语音样本的鼻音化率与VAS相关性。整体组和声门塞音组无显著相关,无声门塞音组多数样本呈显著负相关,提示声门塞音影响鼻音计评价腭咽闭合功能。
要点
- 声门塞音是影响鼻音计评价腭咽闭合功能的重要因素。
- 无声门塞音组多数语音样本鼻音化率与VAS呈显著负相关。
- 有声门塞音者不建议用鼻音计评价腭咽闭合功能。
核心结论
- 声门塞音可影响鼻音计对腭咽闭合功能的评价,存在声门塞音者不建议应用鼻音计进行腭咽闭合功能评价。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纳入2004年8月至2010年8月北京大学口腔医学院·口腔医院口腔颌面外科收治的71例腭裂术后语音障碍患者,男50例、女21例,平均年龄(15.9±6.2)岁。
- 应用鼻音计和鼻咽纤维内镜同步检查,按声门塞音语音评价结果分为整体组71例、声门塞音组34例及无声门塞音组37例。
- 对11个语音样本(单元音1~3号、连续音节4~9号、语句10~11号)的鼻音化率值与VAS值进行Pearson相关分析。
主要发现
- 整体组11个语音样本鼻音化率值与VAS值均呈负相关趋势但无显著相关(r>-0.179且<-0.017,P>0.05)。
- 声门塞音组各语音样本鼻音化率值与VAS值均无显著相关(r>-0.196且<-0.017,P>0.05)。
- 无声门塞音组除1、3、11号样本外,其余样本鼻音化率值与VAS值均呈显著负相关(r>-0.557且<-0.162,P<0.05),其中7号样本最敏感(r=-0.557,P<0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 对腭裂术后语音障碍患者,评价腭咽闭合功能前应进行声门塞音评估。
- 存在声门塞音的患者不宜单用鼻音计评价腭咽闭合功能,鼻音计结果可辅助指导语音训练。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To investigate the influence of glottal stops for the relationship between nasalance and velopharyngeal closure status of cleft palate patients after surgery. Methods: A total of 71 patients with postoperative cleft palate speech disorders treated in the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial surgery, School of Stomatology, Peking University from August 2004 to August 2010 were included. The compensated speech evaluation of cleft palate with or without glottic occlusion was performed in 50 males and 21 females with an average age of (15.9±6.2) years old. The nasal sound meter and nasopharyngeal fiber endoscope were used to record the nasal phonation rate and the score of nasopharyngeal fiber endoscopic visual analog scale (VAS) of the patients. According to the results of glottic plug speech evaluation, the patients were divided into three groups: whole group (without glottic plug), glottic plug group and silent glottic plug group. The nasal phonation rate values and VAS values of 11 speech samples (unit vowel No. 1-3, continuous syllable No. 4-9, sentence 10-11) of the three groups were compared by Pearson analysis. Results: There were 71 patients in the whole group, 34 patients in the glottic plug group and 37 patients in the silent glottis group. There was a negative correlation between nasal phonetic rate and VAS of 11 speech samples in the whole group, however there were no significant difference (r>-0.179 and<-0.017, P>0.017) and no significant correlation between nasal phonetic rate and VAS in glottic occlusion group (r>-0.196 and<-0.017, P>0.05). There was a significant negative correlation between nasal phonetic rate and VAS value of all but No. 1, 3 and 11 speech samples in silent door plug group (P<0.05), among which No. 7 speech sample was the most sensitive sample (r=-0.557, P<0.05). Conclusions: The present study showed the glottal stops could affect the evaluation of the velopharyngeal closure function by using nasometer. Glottal stops should be considered as one important factor for the nasalance. 目的: 探讨腭裂术后语音障碍患者声门塞音对鼻音计评价腭咽闭合状态的影响。 方法: 纳入2004年8月至2010年8月北京大学口腔医学院·口腔医院口腔颌面外科收治的71例腭裂术后语音障碍患者,腭裂代偿语音评价为伴或不伴声门塞音,男性50例,女性21例,年龄(15.9±6.2)岁。应用鼻音计和鼻咽纤维内镜同步检查,记录所有患者鼻音计鼻音化率值和鼻咽纤维内镜视觉模拟量表(visual analog scale,VAS)分值数据,并根据声门塞音语音评价结果将患者分成3组,即整体组(未排除声门塞音)、声门塞音组及无声门塞音组,对3组患者的11个语音样本(单元音1~3号、连续音节4~9号、语句10~11号)鼻音化率值与VAS值进行Pearson相关分析。 结果: 整体组患者71例,声门塞音组患者34例,无声门塞音组37例。整体组患者的11个语音样本鼻音化率值与VAS值间均呈负相关趋势,但均无显著的相关关系(r>-0.179且<-0.017,P>0.05);声门塞音组各语音样本鼻音化率值与VAS值之间均无显著的相关关系(r>-0.196且<-0.017,P>0.05);无声门塞音组除1、3、11号语音样本外,其余各语音样本鼻音化率值与VAS值均呈显著负相关关系(r>-0.557且<-0.162,P<0.05),其中7号语音样本最敏感(r=-0.557,P<0.05)。 结论: 声门塞音是影响鼻音计评价腭咽闭合功能的重要因素,对于存在声门塞音的腭裂语音障碍患者不建议应用鼻音计进行腭咽闭合功能评价,但可以指导语音训练。.
引用
- Gao T, Ma L, Luo Y, et al. [Influence of glottal stops on nasalance and velopharyngeal closure status after cleft palate surgery]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2020. PMID: 33280360. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20200220-00075
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。