文献速递牙周病

牙周炎分期分级系统在病例定义中的一致性与准确性:牙周专家、全科牙医与本科生的比较

The staging and grading system in defining periodontitis cases: consistency and accuracy amongst periodontal experts, general dentists and undergraduate students.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Periodontol · 2020-12-14

结果显示,分期、范围和分级的Fleiss kappa分别为0.48、0.37和0.45;与金标准完全一致率为47.2%。诊断随时间高度一致,检查者间一致性中等,分期准确性几乎完美,分级和范围准确性中等。

要点

  • 检查者间一致性中等:分期kappa=0.48,范围0.37,分级0.45。
  • 分期准确性几乎完美(kappa>0.81),分级和范围准确性中等(kappa>0.41)。
  • 全科牙医培训需加强,以提升分级和范围判断的一致性。

核心结论

  • 诊断随时间高度一致,检查者间一致性中等;分期准确性几乎完美,分级和范围准确性中等。
  • 需要额外努力改善全科牙医的培训。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用Fleiss kappa评估检查者间一致性,组内相关系数(ICC)评估时间一致性,二次加权kappa和完全一致百分比评估准确性。

主要发现

  • 分期、范围和分级的Fleiss kappa分别为0.48、0.37和0.45。
  • 学生分期ICC最高(0.91),全科牙医范围ICC最低(0.79)。
  • 与金标准比较,分期平均kappa>0.81,分级和范围平均kappa>0.41。
  • 所有三个组成部分与金标准完全一致的病例占47.2%。
  • 研究识别了与较低一致性和准确性相关的特定因素。

关键数值与推荐

  • 分期、范围和分级的Fleiss kappa分别为0.48、0.37和0.45。
  • 学生分期ICC为0.91,全科牙医范围ICC为0.79。
  • 与金标准比较,分期平均kappa>0.81,分级和范围平均kappa>0.41。
  • 所有三个组成部分与金标准完全一致的病例占47.2%。

临床怎么用

  • 使用分期分级系统时,分期判断可靠性较高,分级和范围判断需谨慎。
  • 全科牙医需加强培训以提高分级和范围判断的一致性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: The objective of this study was to evaluate consistency and accuracy of the periodontitis staging and grading classification system. METHODS: Thirty participants (10 periodontal experts, 10 general dentists and 10 undergraduate students) and a gold-standard examiner were asked to classify 25 fully documented periodontitis cases twice. Fleiss kappa was used to estimate consistency across examiners. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to calculate consistency across time. Quadratic weighted kappa and percentage of complete agreement versus gold standard were computed to assess accuracy. RESULTS: Fleiss kappa for stage, extent and grade were 0.48, 0.37 and 0.45 respectively. The highest ICC was provided by students for stage (0.91), whereas the lowest ICC by general dentists for extent (0.79). Pairwise comparisons against gold standard showed mean value of kappa >0.81 for stage and >0.41 for grade and extent. Agreement with the gold standard for all three components of the case definition was achieved in 47.2% of cases. The study identified specific factors associated with lower consistency and accuracy. CONCLUSIONS: Diagnosis was highly consistent across time and moderately between examiners. Accuracy was almost perfect for stage and moderate for grade and extent. Additional efforts are required to improve training of general dentists.

来源:J Clin Periodontol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Marini L, Tonetti MS, Nibali L, et al. The staging and grading system in defining periodontitis cases: consistency and accuracy amongst periodontal experts, general dentists and undergraduate students. J Clin Periodontol. 2020. PMID: 33260273. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13406

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。