牙体牙髓病学本科教育的安全感、自信心与性别差异调查
该研究向挪威卑尔根大学2008至2018年间毕业的459名牙医发放电子问卷,分析其新毕业时对根管治疗的安全感、自信心及本科教育是否满足临床需求。共314人(68.4%)应答,男性在安全感与自信心上显著高于女性,71.3%认为本科牙体牙髓教育不充分且希望更多临床训练。
要点
- 新毕业时仅37.3%对根管治疗感到安全,32.0%感到不安全。
- 男性牙医在根管治疗中的安全感与自信心显著高于女性(P < 0.001)。
- 71.3%认为本科牙体牙髓教育不充分,其中70%希望更多临床训练(P < 0.05)。
核心结论
- 研究提示需在牙体牙髓本科教育中提升学生的自我效能感。
- 动手培训是牙医终身学习首选形式。
研究设计与样本
- 电子问卷研究,对象为2008至2018年毕业于挪威卑尔根大学的459名牙医。
- 问卷包含封闭式选项、Likert量表(1-5)及开放式文本选项。
- 共314名牙医应答,应答率68.4%,其中男性87人(27.8%)、女性224人(71.3%),3人未披露性别。
主要发现
- 新毕业时37.3%对根管治疗感到安全,30.7%无所谓,32.0%感到不安全。
- 72.4%对根管治疗自信或非常自信,21.3%无所谓,6.3%信心很少或无信心。
- 84.4%自评根充质量好或很好,15.2%无所谓,仅1人选「不好」,无人选「差」。
- 男性牙医在根管治疗中的安全感显著高于女性(P < 0.001),非常自信的男性显著多于女性(P < 0.001)。
- 以自信为因变量的logistic回归显示,新毕业时感到安全者自我效能约为不安全或无所谓的8倍(OR = 8.49),自评根充质量好或很好者自我效能约为40倍(OR = 40.06)。
关键数值与推荐
- 71.3%认为本科牙体牙髓教育不充分,显著更多牙医(70%)希望更多临床训练(P < 0.05)。
- 47.7%认为需要终身学习,多数偏好动手课程和牙科协会组织的继续教育。
临床怎么用
- 本科牙体牙髓教育应注重提升学生自我效能感,尤其关注女性学生的安全感与自信心。
- 增加动手临床训练以满足毕业生临床需求。
- 终身学习以动手课程和牙科协会继续教育为主要形式。
局限性
- 单中心研究,仅纳入挪威卑尔根大学毕业生,外推需谨慎。
- 基于自评问卷,缺乏客观临床能力评估。
- 横断面设计无法推断因果关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To analyse responses from dental practitioners (DPs) on how secure they felt as a newly graduated dentist, level of confidence or self-efficacy when performing root canal treatment (RCT), and if undergraduate (UG) education in Endodontics adequately met their needs in a dental practice. METHODOLOGY: An electronic questionnaire was sent to 459 dentists who graduated from the University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway, between 2008 and 2018. The survey consisted of questions with closed-end options and Likert scale (1-5). An open-ended free text option was always provided. RESULTS: A total of 314 (68.4%) DPs answered the questionnaire. Of these, 87 (27.8%) were men and 224 (71.3%) were women. Three respondents did not disclose their gender. As a newly graduated dentist, 37.3% of the respondents felt secure when performing RCT, 30.7% felt indifferent, and 32.0% felt insecure. The majority (72.4%) of respondents were either confident or very confident when performing RCT, 21.3% were indifferent, and 6.3% had little or no confidence. A majority of DPs (84.4%) self-evaluated the quality of their root fillings as good or very good, and 15.2% were indifferent. Only one DP selected 'not good' and none selected 'bad'. There were significant gender differences where male DPs felt more secure than female DPs when performing RCT (P < 0.001). A significantly larger number of men were very confident compared to women (P < 0.001). A logistic regression analysis using confidence as a dependent variable to predict self-efficacy revealed that DPs who felt secure when performing RCT as a newly graduated dentist had about 8 times more self-efficacy (odds ratio = 8.49) than those who were insecure or indifferent. Respondents who rated their quality of root fillings as good or very good had forty times more self-efficacy (odds ratio = 40.06) when performing RCT. UG education in endodontics was considered inadequate by 71.3% of the respondents where a significantly larger number of DPs (70%) wanted more clinical training (P < 0.05). About half the DPs (47.7%) stated that there was a need for lifelong learning with majority preferring hands-on courses and continuing dental education organized by dental associations. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study suggest that there is a need to promote self-efficacy during UG education in Endodontics. Hands-on training is the preferred form of lifelong learning for DPs.
引用
- Haug SR, Linde BR, Christensen HQ, et al. An investigation into security, self-confidence and gender differences related to undergraduate education in Endodontics. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 33253460. doi:10.1111/iej.13455
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。