降低饮水氟浓度对龋病和氟斑牙的影响:爱尔兰前后对照研究
该研究对比爱尔兰2002年与2017年8岁儿童龋病和氟斑牙水平,评估2002年牙膏指南与2007年饮水氟浓度调整的效果。结果显示全社区水氟化组龋病无显著变化,无社区水氟化组龋病严重度下降,氟斑牙患病率无显著改变。
要点
- 0.6-0.8 ppm社区水氟化仍有效预防龋病。
- 牙膏指南实施后儿童早期开始刷牙的比例变化小。
- 全水氟化组与非水氟化组龋病严重度差异在2017年缩小。
核心结论
- 0.6-0.8 ppm社区水氟化是有效的龋病预防措施。
- 政策实施后氟斑牙患病率无显著降低,牙膏指南的采纳率较低。
- 全水氟化对乳牙的防龋效果在2017年较2002年有所减弱。
研究设计与样本
- 前后对照研究,比较2017年与2002年随机样本的8岁儿童。
- 2017年都柏林707名、科克-凯里1148名;2002年都柏林679名、科克-凯里565名。
- 临床测量乳牙龋经验(d3vcmft(cde))和恒牙氟斑牙(Dean指数极轻度及以上)。
- 终身社区水氟化暴露分为「全程水氟化」与「无水氟化」。
- 采用多变量回归评估检查年份对龋病和氟斑牙的影响。
主要发现
- 全程水氟化儿童中,2017年与2002年龋病患病率和严重度无统计学显著差异。
- 2017年全程水氟化儿童龋病患病率:都柏林55%,科克-凯里56%。
- 2017年全程水氟化患龋儿童平均d3vcmft(cde):都柏林3.4,科克-凯里3.7。
- 无水氟化儿童2017年龋病严重度(均值4.2)低于2002年(均值4.9),P=0.039。
- 全程水氟化与无水氟化儿童龋病严重度差异在2017年小于2002年(交互P=0.013)。
关键数值与推荐
- 饮水氟浓度调整:2007年从0.8-1.0 ppm降至0.6-0.8 ppm。
- 氟斑牙判定标准:Dean指数极轻度或更高。
- 龋病严重度指标:患龋儿童的平均d3vcmft(cde)。
临床怎么用
- 在饮水氟浓度0.6-0.8 ppm地区,社区水氟化仍可作为龋病预防措施。
- 需关注儿童早期牙膏使用的指导效果,本研究中采纳率较低。
- 全水氟化对乳牙防龋效果可能减弱,应结合其他防龋措施。
局限性
- 研究为前后对照设计,非随机对照,可能存在时间相关混杂。
- 牙膏指南的采纳率仅通过开始刷牙年龄间接评估,信息有限。
- 结果基于爱尔兰特定人群和水氟浓度范围,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Guidance intended to reduce fluoride toothpaste ingestion in early childhood was introduced in Ireland in 2002. In 2007, water fluoride concentration was adjusted from 0.8-1.0 to 0.6-0.8 ppm. The objective of this study was to determine the difference in caries and fluorosis levels following introduction of these 2 policy measures. A before-and-after study compared caries and fluorosis in random samples of 8-y-olds in Dublin (n = 707) and Cork-Kerry (n = 1148) in 2017 with 8-y-olds in Dublin (n = 679) and Cork-Kerry (n = 565) in 2002. Dentinal caries experience (primary teeth, d3vcmft(cde)) and fluorosis (permanent teeth, Dean's index of very mild or higher) were clinically measured. Lifetime exposure to community water fluoridation (CWF) was classified as "full CWF"/"no CWF." Effect of examination year on caries prevalence and severity and fluorosis prevalence was assessed using multivariate regression adjusting for other explanatory variables. There was little change in commencement of fluoride toothpaste use at ≤24 mo following introduction of toothbrushing guidance. Among children with full CWF, there was no statistically significant difference in caries prevalence or severity between 2017 and 2002. In 2017, caries prevalence was 55% in Dublin (full CWF) and 56% in Cork-Kerry (full CWF), and mean d3vcmft(cde) among children with caries was 3.4 and 3.7, respectively. Caries severity was less in 2017 (mean 4.2) than 2002 (mean 4.9) among children with no CWF (P = 0.039). The difference in caries severity between children with full CWF and no CWF was less in 2017 than in 2002 (interaction P = 0.013), suggesting a reduced benefit for CWF in 2017. In 2017, fluorosis prevalence was 18% in Dublin (full CWF) and 12% in Cork-Kerry (full CWF). Fluorosis was predominantly "very mild" with no statistically significant difference between 2017 and 2002. CWF at 0.6 to 0.8 ppm is an effective caries-preventive measure. Results suggested low uptake of toothbrushing guidance, a reduced caries-preventive effect for CWF in primary teeth, and no reduction in fluorosis following introduction of the policy measures.
引用
- James P, Harding M, Beecher T, et al. Impact of Reducing Water Fluoride on Dental Caries and Fluorosis. J Dent Res. 2020. PMID: 33345672. doi:10.1177/0022034520978777
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。