根尖片判读中的搜索满足效应研究
该初步研究探讨牙科临床医生判读根尖片时是否存在搜索满足(SOS)效应。16名观察者分两次判读6张图像,结果显示20.31%的判读集出现真SOS错误,即添加异常后原发病变被漏报。
要点
- 根尖片判读中存在SOS效应,20.31%判读集出现真SOS错误。
- 有添加异常时原发病变报告数从30/64降至25/64。
- 临床需警惕放射判读中的假阴性错误。
核心结论
- 根尖片判读中存在搜索满足效应,20.31%的判读出现真SOS错误。
研究设计与样本
- 初步研究,选取6张图像(1张阳性对照、1张阴性对照、4张含单一隐蔽龋损的实验图像)。
- 16名观察者来自牙髓科和牙周科住院医师及圣路易斯大学高级牙科教育中心校友和教师。
- 每名观察者参与两次间隔至少3个月的判读会话,两次图像互为有无添加异常。
主要发现
- 真SOS错误定义为原发病变单独存在时正确报告,但添加异常后漏报,共发生13/64个判读集(20.31%)。
- 仅含原发病变的图像中,观察者报告30/64个预期原发病变。
- 含人工添加异常的图像中,观察者报告58/64个预期添加异常和25/64个预期原发病变。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用Likert 1-5级评分,3-5分视为存在病变。
- 添加异常包括根尖透射影、吸收、非理想根管充填材料或继发龋。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生判读根尖片时应意识到SOS效应,减少假阴性错误以避免误诊。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Several studies in radiology and medicine have evaluated the satisfaction of search (SOS) error effect in chest radiography, abdominal radiography, osteoradiology, and patients with multiple trauma. No research to date has been published evaluating the possible existence of the SOS error phenomenon made during dental periapical radiograph interpretations. The purpose of the present pilot study was to determine if an SOS error effect exists when dental clinicians interpret periapical radiographs. The null hypothesis was that the detection accuracy will be the same or will improve for the detection of native lesions in the presence of an added abnormality. The alternative hypothesis is that there will be a decrease in detection accuracy for native lesions in the presence of an added abnormality. METHODS: Six images were selected to be part of the present experiment. One of the 6 images served as the positive control, and another image served as the negative control. Four images, each including a single subtle carious lesion, were selected to represent the experimental images. The single subtle carious lesion present within the 4 experimental radiographs served as the native pathology, and an abnormality such as a periapical radiolucency, resorption, inadequate nonideal root canal obturation material, or recurrent carious lesion was artificially inserted into the image as the added pathology. Thus, the second set of images consisted of the same 4 images containing the native pathology including an added pathology that was inserted into the image using Adobe Photoshop CS6 (Adobe, Inc, San Jose, CA). Purposive sampling was obtained from 16 examiners including residents from endodontics and periodontics as well as alumni and faculty from the Saint Louis University Center for Advanced Dental Education, St Louis, MO. Each observer participated as a subject during 2 time-separated sessions. Each session was separated by a minimum period of 3 months' duration in order to prevent memory bias. Before starting each interpretation session, the participants were given verbal instructions. Subjects were instructed to provide a location (by tooth number), identify, and rate the presence of all suspected pathology using a Likert scale of 1-5 (1: definitely normal, 2: probably normal, 3: possibly abnormal, 4: probably abnormal, and 5: definitely abnormal). In the second session, the radiographs that were initially presented containing only the native lesion were presented again with the added abnormality, and vice versa. The observers' reports and confidence ratings were recorded and analyzed. Ratings of 3-5 were considered as being positive for the presence of pathology. RESULTS: A true SOS error occurs when the presence of the native lesion is reported correctly without an added abnormality but is not reported (missed) in the presence of an added abnormality. In our study, a true SOS error occurred in 13 of the 64 interpretation sets (20.31%). There was a total of 64 expected native lesions present within the 4 native images viewed by 16 observers. In the 4 added images, there was a total of 64 expected added findings. In the images containing only native lesions, the observers reported 30 of the 64 expected native lesions. In the images containing an artificially added abnormality, the observers reported 58 of the 64 expected added abnormalities and 25 of the 64 expected native lesions. Observers reported fewer native lesions in the presence of an added abnormality. CONCLUSIONS: The current investigation demonstrated the existence of the SOS effect during periapical radiographic interpretations. In 20.31% of interpretations, a true SOS error occurred. This study is clinically relevant because it can help clinicians in reducing false-negative errors made during radiographic interpretation, thus preventing misdiagnosis.
引用
- Huynh JD, Rhodes SC, Hatton JF, et al. Satisfaction of Search in Periapical Radiograph Interpretation. J Endod. 2020. PMID: 33181168. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2020.11.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。