文献速递口腔修复与种植牙周病

即刻种植联合结缔组织移植的系统评价与Meta分析

Immediate implant placement with or without connective tissue graft: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Periodontol · 2020-11-20

本系统评价与Meta分析评估了单颗即刻种植(IIP)时颊侧应用结缔组织移植(CTG)对中面部软组织垂直变化的影响。纳入5项RCT和3项非随机对照研究,共409颗种植体(IIP+CTG组246颗,IIP组163颗),随访12至108个月。Meta分析显示CTG显著改善中面部软组织垂直稳定性(差异0.41 mm,95%CI [0.21;0.61],p<.001),且中面部垂直软组织不对称≥1 mm的风险降低12倍(RR 12.10,95%CI [2.57;56.91],p=.002),基于GRADE指南给出中等推荐。

要点

  • 即刻种植联合CTG可显著改善中面部软组织垂直稳定性。
  • CTG使中面部垂直软组织不对称≥1 mm的风险降低12倍。
  • 美学区高风险患者(薄龈生物型、颊骨厚度<0.5 mm)应考虑CTG。

核心结论

  • 结缔组织移植有助于即刻种植后中面部软组织稳定性。
  • 在美学区预期中面部退缩风险高时(薄龈生物型、颊骨厚度<0.5 mm),应考虑结缔组织移植。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统评价与Meta分析,检索PubMed、Web of Science、EMBASE和Cochrane数据库至2020年1月。
  • 纳入5项随机对照试验和3项非随机对照研究,共409颗即刻种植体(IIP+CTG组246颗,IIP组163颗),平均随访12至108个月。
  • 仅1项随机对照试验显示低偏倚风险。

主要发现

  • Meta分析显示IIP+CTG与IIP在中面部软组织垂直变化上差异显著,为0.41 mm(95%CI [0.21;0.61],p<.001),有利于软组织移植。
  • IIP+CTG后中面部垂直软组织水平不对称≥1 mm的风险降低12倍(RR 12.10,95%CI [2.57;56.91],p=.002)。
  • 软组织移植在探诊出血方面呈现减少趋势(MD 17%,95%CI [-35%;1%],p=.06)。
  • Meta分析未显示粉色美学评分、边缘骨水平变化和探诊深度有显著差异。
  • 对于水平中面部软组织变化和乳头高度变化,结果不确定。

关键数值与推荐

  • 基于GRADE指南,对即刻种植后使用结缔组织移植给出中等推荐。
  • 中面部软组织垂直变化差异为0.41 mm(95%CI [0.21;0.61],p<.001)。
  • 中面部垂直软组织不对称≥1 mm的风险比RR为12.10(95%CI [2.57;56.91],p=.002)。
  • 探诊出血平均差异为17%(95%CI [-35%;1%],p=.06)。

临床怎么用

  • 在美学区即刻种植时,对于薄龈生物型或颊骨厚度<0.5 mm等高退缩风险患者,建议联合结缔组织移植以改善中面部软组织稳定性。
  • 结缔组织移植可能减少探诊出血,但对粉色美学评分、边缘骨水平和探诊深度无显著影响。

局限性

  • 仅1项随机对照试验显示低偏倚风险,整体证据质量可能受限。
  • 对于水平中面部软组织变化和乳头高度变化,结果不确定。
  • 研究间随访时间范围较大(12至108个月),可能存在异质性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To assess the effect of connective tissue graft (CTG) in terms of vertical mid-facial soft tissue change when applied at the buccal aspect following single immediate implant placement (IIP). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two independent reviewers conducted an electronic literature search in PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE and Cochrane databases as well as a manual search to identify eligible clinical studies up to January 2020. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and non-randomized controlled studies (NRSs) comparing IIP with CTG and without CTG over a mean follow-up of at least 12 months were included for a qualitative analysis. Meta-analyses were performed on data provided by RCTs. RESULTS: Out of 1814 records, 5 RCTs and 3 NRSs reported on 409 (IIP + CTG: 246, IIP: 163) immediately installed implants with a mean follow-up ranging from 12 to 108 months. Only 1 RCT showed low risk of bias. Meta-analysis revealed a significant difference in terms of vertical mid-facial soft tissue change between IIP + CTG and IIP pointing to 0.41 mm (95% CI [0.21; 0.61], p < .001) in favour of soft tissue grafting. This outcome was clinically relevant since the risk for ≥1 mm asymmetry in mid-facial vertical soft tissue level was 12 times (RR 12.10, 95% CI [2.57; 56.91], p = .002) lower following IIP + CTG. Soft tissue grafting also resulted in a trend towards less bleeding on probing (MD 17%, 95% CI [-35%; 1%], p = .06). Meta-analyses did not reveal significant differences in terms of pink aesthetic score, marginal bone level change and probing depth. Results were inconclusive for horizontal mid-facial soft tissue change and papilla height change. Based on GRADE guidelines, a moderate recommendation for the use of a CTG following IIP can be made. CONCLUSION: CTG contributes to mid-facial soft tissue stability following IIP. Therefore, CTG should be considered when elevated risk for mid-facial recession is expected in the aesthetic zone (thin gingival biotype, <0.5 mm buccal bone thickness).

来源:J Clin Periodontol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Seyssens L, De Lat L, Cosyn J, et al. Immediate implant placement with or without connective tissue graft: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Periodontol. 2020. PMID: 33125754. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13397

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。