非手术牙周治疗能否改善全身健康?一项系统综述再评价
该研究对52篇系统综述/meta分析进行再评价,考察非手术牙周治疗对全身疾病结局的影响。结论认为目前缺乏强有力证据支持非手术牙周治疗能改善全身疾病结局。
要点
- 非手术牙周治疗改善全身疾病结局的证据不足,多数综述方法学质量低。
- 现有研究结局以替代终点为主,实际疾病终点罕见。
- 未来需更严谨的综述和原始研究,可借助医疗-牙科匹配数据库。
核心结论
- 目前缺乏强有力证据表明非手术牙周治疗能改善全身疾病结局。
研究设计与样本
- 对已发表的系统综述和meta分析进行系统综述再评价,共纳入52篇研究。
- 使用AMSTAR 2工具评估纳入综述的方法学质量。
主要发现
- 52篇研究中21篇关注糖尿病,15篇关注不良妊娠结局,8篇关注心血管疾病,肥胖和类风湿关节炎各3篇,慢性肾脏病2篇。
- 所有研究中替代终点最常见,其次是生物标志物,实际疾病终点罕见。
- 最常未满足的条目包括方案提前注册、排除个别研究的理由、纳入研究的偏倚风险、meta分析方法的适当性。
临床怎么用
- 临床应认识到非手术牙周治疗对全身疾病结局的改善证据尚不充分。
- 牙周治疗决策仍应基于牙周健康本身,而非期望改善全身结局。
局限性
- 纳入综述方法学质量普遍偏低,影响结论可靠性。
- 多数结局为替代终点,缺乏实际疾病终点数据。
- 未报告纳入综述的具体样本量、P值等数值细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Clinicians frequently stress the importance of maintaining good oral health for multiple reasons, including its link to systemic health. Because periodontal treatment reduces inflammation in oral tissues, some hypothesize it may positively affect systemic outcomes by reducing inflammation in the body. A significant number of systematic reviews (SRs) and meta-analyses (MAs) have evaluated the effect of periodontal treatment on systemic outcomes. However, inconsistent findings and questionable methodological rigor make drawing conclusions difficult. We conducted a systematic review of reviews that studied the effect of nonsurgical periodontal treatment on systemic disease outcomes. We report on outcomes evaluated, categorizing them as biomarkers, and surrogate or clinical endpoints. In addition, we used A MeaSurement Tool to Access systematic Reviews 2 (AMSTAR 2) to evaluate the methodological quality of the reviews. Of the 52 studies included in our review, 21 focused on diabetes, 15 on adverse birth outcomes, 8 on cardiovascular disease, 3 each on obesity and rheumatoid arthritis, and 2 on chronic kidney disease. Across all studies, surrogate endpoints predominated as outcomes, followed by biomarkers and, rarely, actual disease endpoints. Ninety-two percent of studies had "low" or "critically low" AMSTAR 2 confidence ratings. Criteria not met most frequently included advance registration of the protocol, justification for excluding individual studies, risk of bias from individual studies being included in the review, and appropriateness of meta-analytical methods. There is a dearth of robust evidence on whether nonsurgical periodontal treatment improves systemic disease outcomes. Future reviews should adhere more closely to methodological guidelines for conducting and reporting SRs/MAs than has been the case to date. Beyond improved reviews, additional rigorous research on whether periodontal treatment affects systemic health is needed. We highlight the potential of large-scale databases containing matched medical and dental record data to inform and complement future clinical research studying the effect of periodontal treatment on systemic outcomes.
引用
- Taylor HL, Rahurkar S, Treat TJ, et al. Does Nonsurgical Periodontal Treatment Improve Systemic Health? J Dent Res. 2020. PMID: 33089733. doi:10.1177/0022034520965958
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。