西班牙牙科院校本科牙髓病学教学评估
该研究通过电子邮件向西班牙全部23所牙科院校的本科牙髓病学项目负责人发送了英国调查的西班牙语在线版本,回复率为96%。结果显示西班牙本科牙髓教学总体遵循ESE本科课程指南的关键推荐,多数方面与英国相当,但放大设备和超声器械的使用需增加,私立院校在部分分析变量上表现优于公立院校。
要点
- 西班牙牙科院校本科牙髓教学总体遵循ESE本科课程指南,多数方面与英国相当。
- 仅40%的院校学生治疗中度根管病例,90%的院校不使用任何放大设备,仅25%使用超声器械。
- 私立院校在师生比、临床培训时长和牙髓专用临床区域数量上显著优于公立院校。
核心结论
- 西班牙牙科院校本科牙髓教学遵循ESE本科课程指南的关键推荐,多数方面与英国相当。
- 放大设备和超声器械的使用需要增加。
- 私立院校在部分分析变量上报告了比公立院校更好的结果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究将英国开展的调查翻译为西班牙语在线版本,通过电子邮件发送至西班牙全部23所牙科院校的本科牙髓病学项目负责人。
- 回复率为96%。
主要发现
- 95%的牙科院校在四年级教授牙髓病学。
- 100%的院校学生治疗简单根管治疗病例,仅40%的院校学生治疗中度病例。
- 65%的院校由牙髓病学专家的全职教授监督学生,私立牙科院校中这一比例显著更高(P = 0.002)。
- 90%的牙科院校不使用任何类型的放大设备,仅25%使用超声器械。
- 私立牙科院校在临床实践中的师生比显著更好(P = 0.041),临床培训时间显著更多(P = 0.04),牙髓病学专用临床区域数量显著更多(P = 0.010)。
关键数值与推荐
- 西班牙牙科院校在根管治疗培训中同时使用旋转和往复式器械系统。
- 在工作长度确定方法、硅酸盐水门汀使用、冲洗液、诊间封药和根管充填技术方面保持一致。
临床怎么用
- 口腔科智能体医生可参考ESE本科课程指南的关键推荐来评估或设计本科牙髓教学。
- 应关注增加放大设备和超声器械在本科牙髓教学中的使用。
- 私立院校在师生比、临床培训时长和专用临床区域方面的做法可作为改进参考。
局限性
- 研究为问卷调查研究,结果基于项目负责人的自我报告。
- 研究仅涉及西班牙牙科院校,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate the current situation of undergraduate endodontic teaching in Spanish dental schools. METHODOLOGY: An online version, translated into Spanish, of a survey conducted in the UK (Int Endod J 52, 2019, 1077) was sent via email to the undergraduate endodontic programme leads in all 23 Spanish dental schools. RESULTS: The response rate was 96%. In 95% of dental schools, endodontics is taught in the fourth year. Students treat simple root canal treatment cases in 100% of schools and only in 40% treat moderate cases. In 65% of schools, students are supervised by full-time professors who are specialists in Endodontics, significantly more frequently in private dental schools (P = 0.002). Spanish dental schools use both rotary and reciprocating instrumentation systems during endodontic training, with consistency on methods of working length determination, use of silicate-based endodontic cements, irrigating solutions, inter-visit medicaments and canal filling techniques. No type of magnification is used in 90% of dental schools, and only 25% use ultrasonic instruments. Private dental schools have a significantly better staff: student ratio during clinical practice (P = 0.041), spend significantly more hours in clinical training (P = 0.04) and have significantly greater number of clinical areas specifically dedicated to Endodontics (P = 0.010). CONCLUSIONS: Undergraduate endodontic teaching in Spanish dental schools follows the key recommendations of the ESE Undergraduate Curriculum Guidelines (Int Endod J 46, 2013, 1105), being, in most respects, comparable to that carried out in the UK (Int Endod J 52, 2019, 1077). The use of magnification and ultrasonic instruments needs to be increased. Private schools reported better results than public schools in some of the variables that were analysed.
引用
- Segura-Egea JJ, Zarza-Rebollo A, Jiménez-Sánchez MC, et al. Evaluation of undergraduate Endodontic teaching in dental schools within Spain. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 33063865. doi:10.1111/iej.13430
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。