文献速递牙体牙髓病

欧洲两个牙髓病学会会员对深龋露髓管理的问卷调查研究

The management of deep carious lesions and the exposed pulp amongst members of two European endodontic societies: a questionnaire-based study.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2020-10-19

该研究通过结构化在线问卷,调查并比较了爱尔兰牙髓病学会(IES)与意大利牙髓病学会(AIE)会员对深龋及露髓的管理观点,并分析患者因素(年龄、症状)和操作者因素(材料选择、抗生素)对管理的影响。共120名牙医参与(AIE 49%,IES 48%)。结果显示,两组均开展活髓治疗(VPT),但对露髓最适管理及VPT材料选择无一致性;患者症状和年龄显著影响治疗决策及侵入性。

要点

  • 患者症状显著影响治疗计划(P<0.001),两组均更倾向选择根管治疗(RCT)。
  • 患者年龄显著影响治疗选择(无症状P=0.043,有症状P=0.012),老年患者VPT使用更少。
  • 水硬性硅酸钙材料是最常用VPT材料(IES 81%,AIE 69%),但AIE年轻会员偏好氢氧化钙。

核心结论

  • 两组学会会员均开展VPT,但对露髓最适管理及VPT材料选择无一致性。
  • 患者症状和年龄显著影响决策过程及治疗侵入性。

研究设计与样本

  • 结构化在线问卷包含两个病例(18岁和45岁)和两种情景(±轻微症状),含病史和X线片,发送给IES和AIE会员。
  • 共120名牙医参与,代表AIE 49%和IES 48%的会员;使用卡方检验和Fisher精确检验(P<0.05)分析。

主要发现

  • AIE受访者每月VPT量更大,69%超过5例,而IES为22%。
  • 患者症状显著改变治疗计划(P<0.001),两组均更常选择RCT。
  • 患者年龄显著影响治疗选择(无症状P=0.043,有症状P=0.012),老年患者VPT更少。
  • 年轻患者治疗在有无症状时组间无显著差异(P=0.302,P=0.297);老年患者管理组间不同(有症状P=0.041,无症状P=0.044),AIE更多进行RCT。
  • 水硬性硅酸钙材料占IES VPT材料的81%、AIE的69%;AIE年轻会员偏好氢氧化钙。

关键数值与推荐

  • 症状存在时RCT更常被选择(P<0.001)。
  • 老年患者VPT使用更少(无症状P=0.043,有症状P=0.012)。
  • 老年有症状场景AIE比IES更多进行RCT(P=0.041),无症状场景同样(P=0.044)。

临床怎么用

  • 临床决策需考虑患者症状和年龄对VPT与RCT选择的影响。
  • 水硬性硅酸钙材料是多数情况下的常用VPT材料,但年轻AIE会员偏好氢氧化钙。

局限性

  • 问卷研究基于会员样本,结果可能不代表所有牙医。
  • 参与率为AIE 49%、IES 48%,存在无应答偏倚可能。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: To investigate and compare views on management of deep caries and the exposed pulp by Endodontic Society members in Ireland (Irish Endodontic Society [IES]) and Italy (Accademia Italiana di Endodonzia [AIE]). Further aims were to investigate the influence of patient-related factors (age, symptoms) and operator-related factors (material choice, antibiotics) on management. METHODOLOGY: A structured online questionnaire containing two cases (an 18- and 45-year-old) and two scenarios (± mild symptoms), including history and radiograph, was sent to IES and AIE members. The answers were analysed using chi-square and Fisher's exact test (P < 0.05). RESULTS: In total, 120 dentists participated, representing 49% of the AIE and 48% of the IES membership. Age distribution was similar between the societies; however, most AIE members had no further qualifications (63%), while IES respondents generally had a postgraduate endodontic qualification (71%). AIE respondents carried out a larger volume of vital pulp treatment (VPT) per month, with 69% carrying out over five cases, compared with 22% of IES respondents. The presence of patient symptoms significantly altered treatment planning decisions (P < 0.001) with root canal treatment (RCT) more frequently selected in both societies. Patient age significantly influenced treatment choice in the absence (P = 0.043) or presence (P = 0.012) of symptoms with less VPT advocated in older patients. There were no significant differences in the treatment of a young patient in the presence (P = 0.302) or absence of symptoms (P = 0.297); however, older patient management differed between the societies for symptomatic (P = 0.041) and asymptomatic scenarios (P = 0.044) with significantly more RCTs carried out in the AIE than the IES. Hydraulic calcium silicate materials were commonly selected, accounting for 81% of IES and 69% of AIE VPT materials, although younger members of the AIE preferred calcium hydroxide materials. Younger dentists in both societies prescribed less RCT than older age groups. CONCLUSIONS: Although VPT is carried out by members of both societies there was no consistency regarding the most appropriate management for the exposed pulp or the VPT material of choice. Patient symptoms and age significantly influence the decision-making process and invasiveness of treatment. Hydraulic calcium silicate materials were the most commonly advocated material in all groups except young AIE members who preferred calcium hydroxide.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Careddu R, Plotino G, Cotti E, et al. The management of deep carious lesions and the exposed pulp amongst members of two European endodontic societies: a questionnaire-based study. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 32970860. doi:10.1111/iej.13418

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。