指南与共识牙体牙髓病

牙髓病病例报告对PRICE 2020指南的依从性回顾评估

Retrospective evaluation of endodontic case reports published in the International Endodontic Journal and the Journal of Endodontics for their compliance with the PRICE 2020 guidelines.
指南 / 共识 · Int Endod J · 2020-10-13

该研究回顾评估过去五年发表于《国际牙髓病学杂志》和《牙髓病学杂志》的牙髓病病例报告对PRICE 2020指南的依从性。共纳入70篇病例报告,平均得分70.26±4.36%,各条目完成率0%-100%不等,部分领域报告率低。作者应遵循PRICE 2020指南以提高病例报告质量和可重复性。

要点

  • 70篇牙髓病病例报告对PRICE 2020指南的平均依从性得分为70.26%。
  • 病例报告信息、患者视角和图像质量等领域的部分条目报告率最低。
  • 建议作者遵循PRICE 2020指南以提升病例报告质量与可重复性。

核心结论

  • 过去五年牙髓病病例报告在多个领域报告率低,应鼓励作者遵循PRICE 2020指南。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性评估,2020年3月12日检索PubMed,纳入近五年发表于《国际牙髓病学杂志》和《牙髓病学杂志》的70篇牙髓病病例报告,按PRICE 2020条目评分。

主要发现

  • 70篇病例报告的总分范围为56.41%至79.55%,平均70.26±4.36%(SD)。
  • 各适用条目的论文完成率范围0%至100%,47个条目的完成率中位数97.01%,平均73.33±36.28%(SD)。
  • 得分最低的条目位于「病例报告信息」条目6c、6g-i,「患者视角」条目8a和「图像质量」条目12c-d。

关键数值与推荐

  • PRICE 2020指南条目按「0」(未出现)、「1」(出现)、「NA」(不适用)提取并转化为条目完成百分比。

临床怎么用

  • 牙髓病病例报告作者应参照PRICE 2020指南逐条核对,重点完善病例报告信息、患者视角和图像质量等低报告率领域。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To evaluate, retrospectively, the quality of previously published case reports in Endodontics according to the PRICE 2020 guidelines. METHODOLOGY: An electronic literature search was conducted in PubMed database on 12 March 2020, to identify case reports published during the last five years in the International Endodontic Journal and the Journal of Endodontics. For each of the included case reports, information regarding fulfilment of each of the items of the PRICE 2020 guidelines was extracted as '0' (not present in the manuscript), '1' (present in the manuscript) and 'NA' (not applicable) and translated into a score (percentage of items fulfilled). Additionally, the percentage of papers fulfilling each item was calculated. RESULTS: Overall, 70 endodontic case reports were identified. The scores of the papers ranged between 56.41% and 79.55%, with a mean score of 70.26 ± 4.36% (SD). The percentage of papers fulfilling each item of the applicable PRICE 2020 items ranged widely, between 0% and 100%. The median of the percentage of all the items (n = 47) was 97.01% and mean 73.33 ± 36.28% (SD). The lowest scores were recorded for specific items in the following domains: 'Case Report Information'-Items 6c, 6g-i, 'Patient Perspective'-Item 8a and 'Quality of Images'-Items 12c-d. CONCLUSIONS: Several areas with low reporting rates were identified in case reports published over the last 5 years in Endodontics. Authors should be encouraged to follow the PRICE 2020 guidelines in order to increase the quality and improve reproducibility of their case reports.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Berlin-Broner Y, Levin L. Retrospective evaluation of endodontic case reports published in the International Endodontic Journal and the Journal of Endodontics for their compliance with the PRICE 2020 guidelines. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 32961626. doi:10.1111/iej.13415

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。