两种牙髓病例难度评估方法在牙科本科生中的多中心比较
研究纳入四所牙科院校206名四年级牙科本科生,随机分组交叉使用AAE表格与EndoApp评估六例牙髓测试病例,比较知识强化与推荐一致性。两种方法均显著强化知识(P=0.001),但组间无显著差异(P=0.842);EndoApp一致性为实质性(κ=0.668),AAE表格仅轻微(κ=0.176),且65%参与者偏好EndoApp。
要点
- AAE表格与EndoApp均能显著强化牙科本科生的牙髓病例难度评估知识。
- EndoApp与推荐决策的一致性达实质性水平(κ=0.668),AAE表格仅为轻微(κ=0.176)。
- 65%参与者偏好EndoApp,仅11%选择AAE表格,用户友好性各参数均支持EndoApp。
核心结论
- AAE表格与EndoApp均有益于牙科教育,EndoApp在辅助决定治疗或转诊方面可靠,结合用户友好性成为病例难度评估的首选。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心研究,从四所牙科院校招募206名四年级牙科本科生,随机分为A组(n=107)和B组(n=99),交叉使用匿名化AAE表格与EndoApp评估六例牙髓测试病例。
主要发现
- 评估前三例测试病例后,AAE表格与EndoApp的知识强化均显著增加(P=0.001),但两种方法间无显著差异(P=0.842)。
- AAE表格与推荐的一致性为轻微水平(κ=0.176,P<0.001),EndoApp为实质性水平(κ=0.668,P<0.001),差异有统计学意义(P<0.001)。
- 参与者对所有测量参数的用户友好性反馈均偏好EndoApp,65%的队列偏好EndoApp,仅11%选择AAE表格。
临床怎么用
- 在牙科本科教育中可优先选用EndoApp进行牙髓病例难度评估,其用户友好且与推荐决策一致性高。
- AAE表格仍可用于知识强化,但需注意其与推荐决策的一致性较低,可能影响治疗或转诊判断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare the educational benefits and user friendliness of two anonymized endodontic case difficulty assessment (CDA) methods. METHODOLOGY: A cohort (n = 206) of fourth-year undergraduate dental students were recruited from four different Dental Schools and divided randomly into two groups (Group A and B). The participants assessed six test endodontic cases using anonymized versions of the American Association of Endodontists (AAE) case difficulty assessment form (AAE Endodontic Case Difficulty Assessment Form and Guidelines, 2006) and EndoApp, a web-based CDA tool. Group A (n = 107) used the AAE form for assessment of the first three cases, followed by EndoApp for the latter. Group B (n = 99) used EndoApp for the initial three cases and switched to the AAE form for the remainder. Data were collected online and analysed to assess participants' knowledge reinforcement and agreement with the recommendation generated. Statistical analysis was performed using the two-way mixed model anova, Cohen's Kappa (κ) and independent t-tests, with the levels of significance set at P < 0.05. Additionally, participants' feedback and preference for CDA was also gathered. RESULTS: There was a significant increase in knowledge reinforcement for the AAE form and EndoApp (P = 0.001) after assessment of the first three test cases. However, this increase was not significant (P = 0.842) between the CDA methods. Overall, the AAE form and EndoApp had slight (κ = 0.176, P < 0.001) and substantial (κ = 0.668, P < 0.001) levels of agreement, respectively, and the difference was statistically significant (P < 0.001). Participants' feedback on user friendliness favoured EndoApp for all parameters measured. EndoApp was preferred by 65% of the cohort, whereas only 11% chose the AAE form for CDA. CONCLUSIONS: Both the AAE form and EndoApp were beneficial for dental education. EndoApp was reliable in helping with decisions to treat or refer, and combined with user friendliness, it was the preferred choice for CDA.
引用
- Shah PK, Duncan HF, Abdullah D, et al. Comparison of two case difficulty assessment methods on cohorts of undergraduate dental students - a multi-centre study. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 32748456. doi:10.1111/iej.13377
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。