动态导航与徒手开髓洞形预备在模拟钙化根管中的牙体物质损失比较
这项体外研究用40颗3D打印的上下颌中切牙模拟根管钙化,随机采用徒手或动态导航技术进行开髓预备。动态导航组牙体物质损失均值显著低于徒手组(27.2 vs 40.7 mm³,P < .05),且预备速度更快(2.2 vs 7.06分钟,P < .05)。结果表明动态导航在定位模拟前牙钙化根管时能减少牙体损失并提高效率。
要点
- 动态导航开髓的牙体物质损失均值显著低于徒手(27.2 vs 40.7 mm³)。
- 动态导航预备速度显著快于徒手(2.2 vs 7.06分钟)。
- 下颌牙两种技术物质损失差异可忽略(19.0 vs 19.1 mm³)。
核心结论
- 在体外研究局限内,动态导航开髓整体上牙体物质损失显著更少,定位模拟前牙钙化根管精准且高效。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,40颗3D打印上下颌中切牙(#9和#25)模拟根管钙化,随机采用徒手或动态导航开髓。
主要发现
- 动态导航组牙体物质损失均值显著低于徒手组(27.2 vs 40.7 mm³,P < .05)。
- 动态导航组定位钙化根管的最佳精准度(钻路居中)为75%,徒手组为45%,但差异无统计学意义(P > .05)。
- 下颌牙两种技术物质损失差异可忽略(19.0 vs 19.1 mm³,P > .05),但徒手技术出现次优精准度(钻路切向偏移)的几率仍高30%。
- 动态导航预备速度显著快于徒手(2.2 vs 7.06分钟,P < .05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 牙体物质损失均值:动态导航27.2 mm³ vs 徒手40.7 mm³(P < .05)。
- 最佳精准度(钻路居中):动态导航75% vs 徒手45%(P > .05)。
- 下颌牙物质损失均值:动态导航19.0 mm³ vs 徒手19.1 mm³(P > .05)。
- 操作时间:动态导航2.2分钟 vs 徒手7.06分钟(P < .05)。
- 统计学显著性水平设定为.05。
临床怎么用
- 对于模拟钙化根管的前牙开髓,动态导航可减少牙体物质损失并缩短操作时间。
- 下颌牙中两种技术的物质损失差异可忽略,选择时可结合其他因素考量。
局限性
- 本研究为体外研究,使用3D打印牙模拟钙化根管,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The aim of this in vitro study was to compare the speed, qualitative precision, and quantitative loss of tooth structure with freehand and dynamically navigated access preparation techniques for root canal location in 3-dimensional-printed teeth with simulated calcified root canals. METHODS: Forty maxillary and mandibular central incisors (tooth #9 and tooth #25) were 3-dimensionally printed to simulate canal calcification. Under simulated clinical conditions, access preparations were randomly performed with contemporary freehand and dynamically navigated techniques. Qualitative precision and quantitative loss of tooth structure were assessed on postoperative cone-beam computed tomographic scans using ITK-SNAP open-source segmentation (http://www.itksnap.org/). The associations between jaw, technique, volume of substance loss, and operating time were determined using analysis of variance models with Tukey-adjusted post hoc pair-wise comparisons. The kappa statistic was used to determine agreement between 2 independent, blinded raters on the qualitative assessment of the drill path. The association between the technique and jaw and qualitative assessment scoring was compared using the Fisher exact test. The significance level was set at .05. RESULTS: Dynamically navigated accesses resulted in significantly less mean substance loss in comparison with the freehand technique (27.2 vs 40.7 mm3, P < .05). Dynamically navigated accesses were also associated with higher optimal precision (drill path centered) to locate calcified canals in comparison with the freehand technique (75% vs 45%, P > .05). Mandibular teeth were associated with a negligible difference in substance loss between the access techniques (19.0 vs 19.1 mm3, P > .05). However, qualitatively the freehand technique was still prone to 30% higher chance of suboptimal precision (drill path tangentially transported) in locating calcified canals. Overall, dynamically navigated accesses were prepared significantly faster than freehand preparations (2.2 vs 7.06 minutes, P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: Within the limitations of this in vitro study, overall dynamically navigated access preparations led to significantly less mean substance loss with optimal and efficient precision in locating simulated anterior calcified root canals in comparison with freehand access preparations.
引用
- Jain SD, Saunders MW, Carrico CK, et al. Dynamically Navigated versus Freehand Access Cavity Preparation: A Comparative Study on Substance Loss Using Simulated Calcified Canals. J Endod. 2020. PMID: 32795551. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2020.07.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。