文献速递牙周病

牙周风险评估与牙周风险计算器的一致性比较

Comparison of two different periodontal risk assessment methods with regard to their agreement: Periodontal risk assessment versus periodontal risk calculator.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Periodontol · 2020-06-28

该研究回顾性评估50例牙周维护患者,比较牙周风险评估(PRA)与牙周风险计算器(PRC)的一致性。PRA4与PRA6在64%患者中匹配(κ=0.48),PRC两版本完全一致;PRA6与PRCred仅轻微一致(κ=0.34),PRA4与PRCred不一致(κ=0.23)。结论为两种方法一致性极低,疾病严重程度可能改善一致性。

要点

  • PRA与PRC在牙周维护患者中一致性极低,临床选择需谨慎。
  • PRA4与PRA6匹配率64%(κ=0.48),PRC两版本完全一致。
  • PRA6与PRCred仅轻微一致(κ=0.34),PRA4与PRCred不一致(κ=0.23)。

核心结论

  • PRA与PRC之间一致性极低,特定疾病严重程度可能改善一致性。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入50例牙周维护患者(48%女性,年龄63.8±11.2岁),使用PRA和PRC评估牙周风险。
  • PRA评估每牙4个或6个位点的探诊深度和探诊出血(PRA4/PRA6),PRC永久标记或取消标记三个二分因素。
  • 采用加权kappa分析PRA与PRCred(汇总风险类别)的一致性。

主要发现

  • PRA4与PRA6在32例(64%)患者中匹配(κ=0.48,p<.001)。
  • PRC两版本之间100%一致。
  • PRA6与PRCred一致性极低:66%一致,28%差一个类别,6%差两个类别(κ=0.34,p=.001)。
  • PRA4与PRCred不匹配:60%一致,34%差一个类别,6%差两个类别(κ=0.23,p=.13)。
  • 对于SPT诊断的重度牙周炎,PRA6与PRCred弱一致(κ=0.44,p=.004)。

临床怎么用

  • 临床使用PRA或PRC进行牙周风险评估时,应注意两者结果可能不一致。
  • 对于特定疾病严重程度患者,一致性可能改善,可结合临床判断选择工具。

局限性

  • 回顾性研究,样本量较小(50例),可能影响结果的普遍性。
  • PRA和PRC方法均经过修改,可能影响与原始方法的一致性比较。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To evaluate the level of agreement between the periodontal risk assessment (PRA) and the periodontal risk calculator (PRC). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Periodontal risk was retrospectively assessed among 50 patients using PRA and PRC. Both methods were modified. PRA by assessing probing pocket depths and bleeding on probing at four (PRA4) and six (PRA6) sites per tooth, PRC by permanently marking or unmarking the dichotomously selectable factors "irregular recall," "oral hygiene in need of improvement" and "completed scaling and root planing" for PRC. Agreement between PRA and PRCred (summarized risk categories) was determined using weighted kappa. RESULTS: Fifty patients enrolled in periodontal maintenance (48% female, age: 63.8 ± 11.2 years) participated. PRA4 and PRA6 matched in 32 (64%) patients (κ-coefficient = 0.48, p < .001). There was 100% agreement between both PRC versions. There was minimal agreement of PRA6 and PRCred (66%, 28% one different category, 6% two different categories; κ-coefficient = 0.34; p = .001). PRA4 and PRCred did not match (60% agreement, 34% one different category, 6% two different categories; κ-coefficient = 0.23; p = .13). For the SPT diagnosis of severe periodontitis, PRA6 and PRCred agreed weakly (κ-coefficient = 0.44; p = .004). CONCLUSION: PRA and PRC showed a minimal agreement. Specific disease severity may result in improved agreement.

来源:J Clin Periodontol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Petsos H, Arendt S, Eickholz P, et al. Comparison of two different periodontal risk assessment methods with regard to their agreement: Periodontal risk assessment versus periodontal risk calculator. J Clin Periodontol. 2020. PMID: 32512625. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13327

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。