改良电子探针尖端设计对牙周探诊不适感的影响:标准化探诊力的随机对照试验
两种探针尖的VAS评分相似(中位数13.5对14,p=.3713),但直端在上颌与更低的VAS评分相关(p=.01);两种探诊方式总体疼痛水平均较低。
要点
- 两种探针尖总体VAS评分相似,疼痛水平均较低。
- 直端探针尖在上颌可能被感知为更舒适。
- 个体VAS评分在两次就诊间及两种探针尖间呈高度相关。
核心结论
- 两种探诊方式总体疼痛水平均较低,直端探针尖在上颌可能被感知为更舒适。
主要发现
- 两种探针尖VAS评分相似,球端中位数13.5,直端中位数14,p=.3713。
- 直端探针尖在上颌与更低的VAS评分相关,p=.01。
- 总体VAS值不因上下颌或就诊次数而异。
- 个体VAS评分在两次就诊间(R2=.86)及两种探针尖间(R2=0.64)高度相关,p<.0001。
关键数值与推荐
- 球端探针尖直径0.6 mm,探诊力408 kPa;直端探针尖直径0.45 mm,探诊力726 kPa。
临床怎么用
- 临床牙周探诊可选用球端或直端电子探针尖,两者疼痛水平均较低;上颌探诊时直端可能更舒适。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: This study evaluated pain associated with electronic probing comparing two commercially available probe tip designs using standardized force. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Twenty adult patients with slight-moderate chronic periodontitis received periodontal probing using controlled-force electronic probe at 2 visits. In visit 1, a random arch was probed with either a ball-end (0.6 mm diameter, 408 kPa; Test) or straight (0.45 mm diameter, 726 kPa; Control) probe tip. The opposing arch was then probed using the other probe tip. Discomfort associated with each probing episode was recorded using visual analogue scale (VAS). 7 days later, tip assignments were alternated from visit 1 and VAS re-scored. VAS scores were compared by probe tip, arches and visits. RESULTS: Both tips provided similar VAS scores (median 13.5 for ball-end and 14 for straight, p = .3713). However, the straight tip was associated with decreased VAS scores in the maxilla (p = .01). Overall, VAS values did not differ by arch or study visit. Individual VAS scores showed high levels of correlation between study visits and between tips used (R2 = .86 and 0.64, respectively, p < .0001). CONCLUSIONS: Both probing approaches were associated with low levels of pain on probing. The straight tip may be perceived as more comfortable in the maxilla.
引用
- Harrison PL, Stuhr S, Shaddox LM, et al. The impact of a modified electronic probe tip design on patient perception of discomfort during periodontal probing using standardized probing force: A randomized controlled trial. J Clin Periodontol. 2020. PMID: 32418217. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13308
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。