文献速递牙体牙髓病

运动伪影及校正对CBCT诊断根尖周炎准确性的影响:基于人类尸体的体外研究

Impact of motion artefacts and motion-artefact correction on diagnostic accuracy of apical periodontitis in CBCT images: an ex vivo study in human cadavers.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2020-06-11

本研究以40个固定的人类颌骨标本中的77个牙根为对象,在模拟3毫米运动(点头、侧旋、震颤)下,用四种CBCT设备(有无运动伪影校正)采集图像,由三名观察者盲法评估图像可解释性及根尖周炎存在与否,以组织病理学为参考标准。结果显示运动伪影显著降低诊断准确性,而运动伪影校正系统可提高图像可解释性和诊断准确性,使其与无运动对照图像相当。

要点

  • 运动伪影会显著降低CBCT诊断根尖周炎的准确性。
  • 运动伪影校正系统能改善图像可解释性并提高诊断准确性。
  • 校正后诊断准确性可与无运动对照图像相媲美。

核心结论

  • CBCT图像诊断根尖周炎的准确性取决于运动伪影的存在,运动时准确性较低。
  • 运动伪影校正系统对图像可解释性和诊断准确性有积极影响。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于40个福尔马林固定的人类颌骨标本的临床和影像学检查,选取45颗牙齿(磨牙和前磨牙)中的77个牙根,涵盖不同疾病和治疗状态。
  • 标本安装在模拟3毫米运动类型(点头、侧旋和震颤)的机器人上,在四台CBCT设备上采集有和无运动(对照)的图像:Cranex 3Dx、Orthophos SL 3D和Promax 3D Mid无运动伪影校正,Promax 3D Mid和X1有运动伪影校正。
  • 三名观察者盲法评估图像是否可解释以及根尖周炎是否存在(5步概率指数),以组织病理学作为根尖周炎存在的参考标准。

主要发现

  • 观察者间一致性:对照图像为实质性,运动伪影校正图像为中等,无运动伪影校正图像为一般。
  • 存在运动时,运动伪影校正减少了被评分为不可解释或疾病状态不确定(5步概率指数中评分为3)的图像百分比。
  • 对照图像并非完全准确(存在假阳性和假阴性结果;AUC 0.750-0.799)。
  • 有运动且无运动伪影校正的图像(AUC 0.541-0.709)准确性显著低于对照图像(P < 0.05)。
  • 有运动伪影校正时,准确性可与对照图像相媲美(AUC 0.732-0.790)。

临床怎么用

  • 临床中若CBCT扫描期间发生运动,应考虑使用具备运动伪影校正功能的设备或软件以提高诊断准确性。
  • 对于根尖周炎的CBCT诊断,需注意运动伪影可能导致准确性下降,校正后准确性可接近无运动状态。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To assess the impact of motion artefacts and motion-artefact correction on diagnostic accuracy of apical periodontitis (AP) in CBCT images. METHODOLOGY: Based on clinical and radiographic inspection of 40 formalin-fixated human jaw specimens, 77 roots in 45 teeth (molars and premolars), with various disease and treatment state, were selected. The specimens were mounted on a robot simulating 3-mm movement types (nodding, lateral rotation and tremor). CBCT images with and without (controls) movements were acquired in four CBCT units: without motion-artefact correction in Cranex 3Dx, Orthophos SL 3D, and Promax 3D Mid, and with motion-artefact correction in Promax 3D Mid and X1. Three observers blindly assessed (i) whether the images were interpretable and (ii) if AP was present (5-step probability index). Histopathology provided the reference standard for presence of AP. Weighted Kappa statistics described inter-observer agreement. Estimates of diagnostic accuracy were assessed by means of receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. Area under the curve (AUC) provided a measure of accuracy, and paired-sample AUC difference tests compared differences amongst the CBCT units and movement types. RESULTS: Observer agreement was substantial for control images, moderate for motion-artefact corrected images and fair for images without motion-artefact correction. When movement was present, motion-artefact correction reduced the percentage of images scored as noninterpretable or with uncertain disease state (score 3 in the 5-step probability index). Control images were not perfectly accurate (both false-positive and false-negative results were present; AUC 0.750-0.799). Images acquired with movement and without motion-artefact correction (AUC 0.541-0.709) were associated with significantly lower accuracy than control images (P < 0.05). With motion-artefact correction, accuracy was comparable to that observed in control images (AUC 0.732-0.790). CONCLUSIONS: Diagnostic accuracy of apical periodontitis in CBCT images was dependent on the presence of motion artefacts (i.e. lower accuracy associated with the presence of movement). Motion-artefact correction systems positively influenced image interpretability and diagnostic accuracy.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Spin-Neto R, Kruse C, Hermann L, et al. Impact of motion artefacts and motion-artefact correction on diagnostic accuracy of apical periodontitis in CBCT images: an ex vivo study in human cadavers. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 32395820. doi:10.1111/iej.13326

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。