两种器械系统的清洁、成形与消毒能力:微CT与组织细菌学关联分析
研究采用微计算机断层扫描与组织细菌学关联分析法,比较XP-endo Shaper与Reciproc Blue在离体磨牙根管中的清洁、成形和消毒能力。结果显示Reciproc Blue成形能力更优(未预备面积约19% vs 26%,P<.05),但两者清洁和消毒效果相似(P>.05),不规则根管和难触及区域均未彻底清洁消毒。
要点
- Reciproc Blue成形能力优于XP-endo Shaper(未预备面积19% vs 26%,P<.05)。
- 两者清洁和消毒效果无显著差异(P>.05)。
- 不规则根管和难触及区域均未彻底清洁消毒。
核心结论
- Reciproc Blue成形能力优于XP-endo Shaper,但两者清洁和消毒效果相似。
- 所有测试系统均未能彻底清洁和消毒不规则根管及难触及区域。
研究设计与样本
- 离体下颌和上颌磨牙伴根尖周炎,经微CT分析解剖相似性配对,XP-endo Shaper组n=16,Reciproc Blue组n=16。
- 使用2.5%次氯酸钠冲洗,预备前后微CT扫描计算未预备面积,组织细菌学评估残留细菌和牙髓组织残留。
主要发现
- 全根管未预备面积:XP-endo Shaper约26%,Reciproc Blue约19%(P<.05);根尖部未预备面积分别为30%和23%(P>.05)。
- 全根管无细菌比例:Reciproc Blue 37.5%,XP-endo Shaper 44%;仅根尖部无细菌比例均为56%。
- 全根管无牙髓组织残留比例均为31%,仅根尖部为50%。
- 两种器械在牙髓组织残留量和细菌/组织阴性病例数上无显著差异(P>.05)。
临床怎么用
- Reciproc Blue在成形能力上可能减少未预备面积,但清洁和消毒效果与XP-endo Shaper相似。
- 对于不规则根管和难触及区域,需额外考虑辅助清洁消毒措施。
局限性
- 离体牙研究,样本量每组16个根管,结果需临床验证。
- 仅评估两种器械系统,未比较其他辅助方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: This study assessed the cleaning, shaping, and disinfection abilities of 2 instrumentation systems in molar root canals using a novel correlative analytical approach. METHODS: The root canals from extracted mandibular and maxillary molars with apical periodontitis were pair matched according to anatomic similarities as determined by micro-computed tomographic analysis and prepared with either XP-endo Shaper (FKG Dentaire, La Chaux-de-Fonds, Switzerland) (n = 16) or Reciproc Blue (VDW, Munich, Germany) (n = 16) instruments and 2.5% sodium hypochlorite irrigation. Pre- and postpreparation micro-computed tomographic scans were used to identify and calculate the unprepared surface areas (shaping), which were histobacteriologically evaluated for the presence of residual bacteria (disinfection) and pulp tissue remnants (cleaning) in each canal third. RESULTS: Unprepared canal surface areas for XP-endo Shaper and Reciproc Blue in the full canal length were approximately 26% and 19% (P < .05), respectively (30% and 23% in the apical part of the canal, P > .05). Preparation with Reciproc Blue resulted in 37.5% canals free of bacteria in all sections examined and 56% in the apical sections only. XP-endo Shaper resulted in 44% canals free of bacteria in all sections, and 56% in the apical part of the canal only. Pulp tissue remnants were not observed in 31% (all canal sections) and 50% (apical canal sections) of specimens from both instrument systems. No significant differences were observed between instruments when comparing the amount of pulp tissue remnants and the number of cases negative for bacteria and tissue remnants (P > .05). CONCLUSIONS: Although the Reciproc Blue instrument had superior shaping ability in comparison with XP-endo Shaper, both systems performed similarly in cleaning and disinfecting root canals. Irregular canals and difficult-to-reach areas were not thoroughly cleaned and disinfected by any of the tested systems.
引用
- Pérez AR, Ricucci D, Vieira GCS, et al. Cleaning, Shaping, and Disinfecting Abilities of 2 Instrument Systems as Evaluated by a Correlative Micro-computed Tomographic and Histobacteriologic Approach. J Endod. 2020. PMID: 32362378. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2020.03.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。