外部宫颈吸收的手术管理:治疗结果与分类的回顾性观察研究
本研究回顾性分析2015-2018年间13例患者14颗行手术修复的外部宫颈吸收(ECR)患牙,评估生存率与临床成功率,并比较Heithersay二维与Patel三维分类的可靠性。随访平均20个月,所有患牙均存活,但仅11例达到临床成功;两种分类预测治疗结果均有明显局限,观察者间一致性分别为中等(0.69)和弱(0.40)。结论认为ECR治疗长期成功可预测,但严格依赖病例选择和操作技巧,分类系统仍需改进。
要点
- Heithersay分类观察者间一致性中等(κ=0.69),Patel分类一致性弱(κ=0.40)。
- 两种分类系统在预测治疗结果方面均存在明显局限。
核心结论
- ECR是一种复杂、侵袭性且少见的外吸收形式,治疗长期成功可预测但严格依赖病例选择和操作技巧。
- 现有ECR分类系统类别间存在模糊性,观察者间一致性仅为中等至弱,需进一步改进以用于未来研究。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性观察研究,纳入2015-2018年间在英国一家教学牙科医院接受ECR手术管理的13例患者共14颗患牙。
- 由2名独立牙科医生使用Heithersay和Patel分类评估根尖片和锥形束CT(CBCT),3周后由1名操作者重复评估,采用Cohen kappa分析观察者间和观察者内一致性。
主要发现
- 13例患者(6女7男)平均年龄41岁,共14颗ECR患牙,平均随访20个月。
- 随访时所有病例均存活,但描述牙髓成功、综合修复完整性和吸收过程停止的临床成功仅11例达到。
- Heithersay分类观察者间一致性中等(κ=0.69),Patel分类观察者间一致性弱(κ=0.40)。
临床怎么用
- ECR手术修复可获得较高生存率,但临床成功需严格选择病例并依赖操作技巧。
- 现有二维和三维分类系统在预测治疗结果方面均有局限,临床决策不宜过度依赖分类。
局限性
- 回顾性设计,样本量小(13例患者14颗患牙),随访时间平均仅20个月。
- 分类评估仅由2名观察者完成,观察者内一致性结果未在摘要中报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The aims of this study were to assess the survival and clinical success of patients with teeth with external cervical resorption (ECR) who underwent surgical repair, to assess the reliability of using 2 different classification systems for ECR (Heithersay 2-dimensional classification and Patel 3-dimensional classification), and to identify if a 3-dimensional classification is a viable alternative. METHODS: A retrospective study was performed in a teaching dental hospital in England. The inclusion criteria were limited to patients who underwent surgical management of ECR between 2015 and 2018. Both periapical radiographs and cone-beam computed tomographic scans of 13 patients were assessed by 2 independent dental practitioners using the Heithersay and Patel classifications. The same radiographic assessment of those records was then repeated 3 weeks later by 1 operator. These data were tested using the Cohen kappa analysis to determine inter- and intraobserver agreement. RESULTS: A total of 14 teeth affected with ECR were identified in 13 patients (6 women and 7 men) with a mean age of 41 years. The mean follow-up was 20 months. At follow-up, survival was noted in all cases; however, clinical success describing endodontic success, comprehensive restorative integrity, and arrest of the resorptive process was only met in 11 cases. Although helpful in describing the lesions, both classification systems displayed considerable limitations in predicting treatment outcome. A measure of Cohen kappa regarding interobserver reliability found the Heithersay classification to provide a moderate level of agreement (0.69), whereas the Patel classification provided a weak level of agreement (0.40). CONCLUSIONS: ECR is a complex, aggressive, and uncommon form of external resorption. The long-term success of the treatment is predictable but strictly related to careful case selection and operative skill. In reference to ECR classifications, ambiguity still exists between their distinctive categories, leading to moderate and weak levels of interobserver agreement. Further improvement is required to enhance their use in future research.
引用
- Jebril A, Aljamani S, Jarad F, et al. The Surgical Management of External Cervical Resorption: A Retrospective Observational Study of Treatment Outcomes and Classifications. J Endod. 2020. PMID: 32334857. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2020.03.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。