维持牙髓活力:选择性去腐与MTA直接盖髓的成本效益分析
该研究从德国公私混合支付方视角,用马尔可夫模型模拟30岁患者深龋恒磨牙,比较选择性(SE)与非选择性(NS)去腐联合MTA或氢氧化钙(CH)直接盖髓的成本效益,主要结局为牙齿存留时间。结果显示SE联合MTA策略具有>95%的成本效益概率,平均存留37.37年、费用2140欧元。
要点
- 选择性去腐联合MTA直接盖髓是最具成本效益的策略。
- 避免牙髓暴露比暴露后如何管理对成本效益影响更大。
- 不同策略间总体差异有限,可结合术者经验与患者期望个体化选择。
核心结论
- 选择性去腐并在牙髓暴露时使用MTA直接盖髓是最具成本效益的策略。
研究设计与样本
- 采用德国公私混合支付方视角,构建马尔可夫模型模拟30岁患者深龋恒磨牙。
- 比较SE与NS去腐,牙髓暴露时分别用MTA或CH直接盖髓,随访至患者终生。
- 模型参数来源于成对与贝叶斯网络荟萃分析及其他数据源,并做蒙特卡洛微模拟与敏感性分析。
主要发现
- SE联合MTA策略具有>95%的概率具成本效益,牙齿平均存留37.37年、费用2140欧元。
- 替代策略均更贵且效果更差,该排序在敏感性分析中稳健。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要健康结局为牙齿存留时间。
- 成本来自德国收费项目目录并结合微成本核算。
临床怎么用
- 临床应优先选择选择性去腐以避免牙髓暴露,暴露后可选MTA直接盖髓。
- 决策时可结合术者专业经验与患者期望进行个体化调整。
局限性
- 模型基于德国医疗体系与收费数据,外推需谨慎。
- 研究为模型模拟,非直接临床试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: When managing deep carious lesions, dentists can maintain pulp vitality via (1) avoiding pulp exposure and complications by performing selective (SE) instead of non-selective (NS) carious tissue removal, and/or (2) treat exposed pulps by direct capping with mineral-trioxide-aggregate (MTA) instead of calcium hydroxide (CH). We assessed the cost-effectiveness of SE vs. NS combined with direct pulp capping using MTA vs. CH. METHODS: A mixed public-private-payer perspective within German healthcare was applied. We modeled a permanent molar with a deep carious lesion and a vital asymptomatic pulp. The lesion was treated by SE/NS and, in case of exposure, direct pulp capping using MTA/CH. The tooth was followed over the lifetime of an initially 30-year-old patient using Markov-models, informed by pairwise and Bayesian network meta-analyses and further data sources. The primary health outcome was tooth-retention time. Costs were derived from German fee item catalogues, combined with micro-costing. Monte-Carlo micro-simulation was performed, and uncertainty introduced via probabilistic and univariate sensitivity analyses. Value-of-information-analysis (VOI) was performed to quantify the value of further research. RESULTS: SE and, in case of pulp exposure, MTA had a high chance (>95 %) of being cost-effective, with teeth being retained for 37.37 years at costs of 2140 Euro in mean. Alternative strategies were both more costly and less effective; this ranking was robust in sensitivity analyses. The VOI was 1.18 Euro per treated case and 12.86 million Euro on population-level. CONCLUSION: Selective carious tissue removal and, in case of pulp exposure, direct capping with MTA was the most cost-effective strategy. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Avoiding pulp exposure was more relevant for cost-effectiveness than how the exposed pulp was managed. Overall differences remain limited, though, and dentists may want to tailor treatment strategies according to their expertise and patients' expectations.
引用
- Emara R, Krois J, Schwendicke F, et al. Maintaining pulpal vitality: Cost-effectiveness analysis on carious tissue removal and direct pulp capping. J Dent. 2020. PMID: 32259533. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103330
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。