美国儿童口腔科医生口内X线辐射减量方法调查(含矩形准直器使用)
该研究通过电子问卷向7087名AAPD成员调查儿童口腔科医生在口内X线摄影中的辐射减量实践,重点是矩形准直器的使用情况。共1124名儿童口腔科医生或住院医师回应(应答率16%,误差±2.7%),超过90%表示遵循ADA-AAPD辐射暴露指南,但仅33.5%知晓IGCD,仅22.3%使用矩形准直器。结论认为受访者虽自认合规,但多数不熟悉IGCD推荐,矩形准直器使用有限。
要点
- 超过90%受访者表示遵循ADA-AAPD辐射指南,但仅33.5%知晓IGCD推荐。
- 仅22.3%(n=220)使用矩形准直器,非使用者主因不熟悉(33.3%)或担心锥切增加(30.2%)。
- 11.6%受访者不知晓 radiographic 设备定期检查的监管要求,4.1%认为铅围裙可选。
核心结论
- 受访儿童口腔科医生虽自认遵循ADA-AAPD指南,但多数不知晓IGCD推荐,矩形准直器使用有限。
- 数字X线摄影几乎普及,但矩形准直器等剂量减量策略应用不足。
研究设计与样本
- 经机构审查委员会批准的电子问卷调查,发送给7087名AAPD成员。
- 调查涵盖执业者人口学特征、X线技术及包括矩形准直器在内的剂量减量实践。
- 共1124名儿童口腔科医生或儿童口腔住院医师回应,应答率16%,误差±2.7%。
- 采用二项检验、χ2检验和Fisher精确检验进行统计分析。
主要发现
- 最大群体(23.8%)为2010年后毕业。
- 超过90%表示遵循ADA-AAPD辐射暴露指南,但仅33.5%知晓IGCD。
- 几乎所有受访者使用直接数字系统、存储荧光板或两者兼用。
- 仅22.3%(n=220)使用矩形准直器。
- 非使用者中33.3%不熟悉准直器,30.2%担心锥切增加;11.6%不知晓设备定期检查监管要求,4.1%认为铅围裙可选。
关键数值与推荐
- ADA-AAPD辐射暴露指南被超过90%受访者报告遵循。
- IGCD知晓率仅33.5%。
- 矩形准直器使用率22.3%(n=220)。
- 非使用者不熟悉准直器占33.3%,担心锥切增加占30.2%。
- 11.6%不知晓 radiographic 设备定期检查监管要求,4.1%认为铅围裙可选。
临床怎么用
- 治疗儿童的牙医应熟悉ADA-AAPD辐射暴露指南。
- 应考虑使用IGCD推荐的剂量减量策略,包括矩形准直器。
局限性
- 应答率16%,存在无应答偏倚可能。
- 误差范围为±2.7%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The authors conducted a survey of the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (AAPD) to determine awareness of the Image Gently Campaign in Dentistry (IGCD) and to ascertain radiologic practices, including radiation dose-reduction strategies such as rectangular collimation. METHODS: An institutional review board approved an electronic survey sent to 7,087 AAPD members covering practitioner demographic characteristics, radiographic techniques, and dose-reduction practices, including rectangular collimation. Responses were tabulated and analyzed using binomial tests, χ2 tests, and Fisher exact tests. RESULTS: A total of 1,124 pediatric dentists or residents in pediatric dentistry responded, (response rate 16%, margin of error ± 2.7%). The largest group (23.8%) graduated after 2010. More than 90% indicated that they followed American Dental Association (ADA)-AAPD radiation exposure guidelines, but only 33.5% were aware of IGCD. Almost all respondents used direct digital systems, storage phosphor plates, or both. Only 22.3% (n = 220) used rectangular collimation. Nonusers indicated that they were unfamiliar with collimation (33.3%) or concerned about potential for increased cone cuts (30.2%), 11.6% of respondents were unaware of any regulatory requirements for inspections of radiographic equipment recurring at regular intervals, and 4.1% of respondents considered use of lead aprons optional. CONCLUSIONS: Although the pediatric dentists surveyed believe they are in compliance with ADA-AAPD guidelines, most are unaware of IGCD recommendations. Use of digital radiography is almost ubiquitous, but use of rectangular collimation is limited. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Dentists treating children should be familiar with ADA-AAPD radiation exposure guidelines and should consider using the dose-reduction strategies recommended by IGCD.
引用
- Campbell RE, Wilson S, Zhang Y, et al. A survey on radiation exposure reduction methods including rectangular collimation for intraoral radiography by pediatric dentists in the United States. J Am Dent Assoc. 2020. PMID: 32222177. doi:10.1016/j.adaj.2020.01.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。