振荡旋转式与其它电动牙刷随机对照研究的系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析检索PubMed-MEDLINE,纳入2009至2019年比较振荡旋转式(OR)与其它电动牙刷的随机对照试验,共15篇纳入、12篇用于Meta分析。结果显示OR牙刷在全口菌斑减少(Rustogi改良海军菌斑指数,P<.01)和出血位点数量(P<.001)上显著优于其它电动牙刷,但改良牙龈指数(P>.05)和牙龈出血指数(P>.05)无显著差异。
要点
- OR电动牙刷在全口菌斑减少上显著优于其它电动牙刷(P<.01)。
- OR电动牙刷在减少出血位点数量上显著优于其它电动牙刷(P<.001)。
- 改良牙龈指数和牙龈出血指数未见显著差异(P>.05)。
核心结论
- 有一定证据表明OR电动牙刷可能比其它电动牙刷(尤其是声波式)去除更多菌斑并减少出血位点。
- OR牙刷在改良牙龈指数和牙龈出血指数上未显示显著优势。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,遵循PRISMA指南,采用PICO格式制定检索策略。
- 检索PubMed-MEDLINE数据库,纳入2009年1月1日至2019年3月1日发表的随机对照临床试验。
- 检索得到454篇文章,21篇下载评审,15篇纳入报告,12篇用于Meta分析。
主要发现
- Meta分析显示OR牙刷在全口菌斑减少(Rustogi改良海军菌斑指数)上显著优于其它电动牙刷(P<.01)。
- OR牙刷在牙龈炎(出血位点数量)上显著优于其它电动牙刷(P<.001)。
- 改良牙龈指数(P>.05)和牙龈出血指数(P>.05)无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准为比较OR牙刷与其它电动牙刷的随机对照临床试验。
- 所有纳入研究均评估菌斑去除和牙龈炎症指数。
- 全口菌斑减少用Rustogi改良海军菌斑指数评估,牙龈炎用出血位点数量评估。
临床怎么用
- OR电动牙刷可能比其它电动牙刷(尤其是声波式)去除更多菌斑并减少出血位点。
- 临床推荐时可考虑OR牙刷对菌斑和出血位点的优势,但需结合患者具体情况。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to systematically review and analyze the difference in efficacy of oscillating-rotating toothbrushes compared with other powered toothbrushes. METHODS: The authors performed a systematic search of the literature according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. The authors used the population, intervention, comparison, and outcome format to develop a search strategy to answer the study question. The authors searched PubMed-MEDLINE databases. Inclusion criteria were randomized controlled clinical trials comparing oscillating-rotating (OR) toothbrushes with other powered toothbrushes published from January 1, 2009 through March 1, 2019. RESULTS: The authors' search resulted in 454 articles; 21 articles were downloaded for review, 15 articles were included in the report, and 12 could be used for meta-analysis. All of the studies were randomized controlled clinical trials that assessed plaque removal and gingival inflammation indexes. Results of the meta-analysis of the randomized controlled clinical trials showed that OR toothbrushes had superior, statistically significant outcomes for whole-mouth plaque reduction, assessed using the Rustogi Modified Navy Plaque Index (P < .01), and gingivitis, assessed by using number of bleeding sites (P < .001), but not for the modified gingival index (P > .05) or gingival bleeding index (P > .05). PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: There is some evidence to suggest that OR powered toothbrushes might remove more plaque and reduce the number of bleedings sites better than other powered toothbrushes, specifically, sonic action toothbrushes.
引用
- Clark-Perry D, Levin L. Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies comparing oscillating-rotating and other powered toothbrushes. J Am Dent Assoc. 2020. PMID: 32111341. doi:10.1016/j.adaj.2019.12.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。