CAMBRA儿童龋风险评估工具在维多利亚幼儿中的测量特性研究
基于VicGeneration出生队列的二次数据,5名检查者对214名18月龄儿童应用CAMBRA龋风险评估工具(CRAT),并与36、48月龄龋病发生比较。该工具重测信度近乎完美,但效标效度和反应度不足,曲线下面积约0.50,且高估高危儿童比例。结论认为现行CAMBRA CRAT对维多利亚幼儿未来龋病预测不佳。
要点
- CAMBRA CRAT在18月龄幼儿中重测信度近乎完美,但预测36、48月龄龋病的效标效度不足。
- 18月龄高危比例达66%,36和48月龄龋患病率分别为18%和35%,提示风险高估。
- 二分类风险下预测36和48月龄龋病的敏感度为74%和70%,特异度为35%和36%。
核心结论
- 现行CAMBRA CRAT对维多利亚幼儿未来龋病预测不佳,并高估高危儿童比例,可能推动过度治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 基于VicGeneration出生队列的二次数据分析,5名检查者各自对214名18月龄儿童应用CAMBRA CRAT评定风险。
- 分析方法参考COSMIN清单,将18月龄风险状态与36、48月龄龋病发生比较。
主要发现
- 18月龄低、中、高危比例分别为17%、17%和66%,36和48月龄龋患病率分别为18%和35%。
- 龋风险分类的检查者间与检查者内信度近乎完美。
- 效标效度与反应度的曲线下面积约0.50。
关键数值与推荐
- 二分类风险下,CAMBRA CRAT预测36和48月龄龋病的敏感度分别为74%和70%,特异度分别为35%和36%。
- 效标效度与反应度曲线下面积约0.50。
临床怎么用
- 该工具可用于了解幼儿龋风险分层,但不宜单独作为预测未来龋病的依据。
- 选择龋风险评估工具时应关注其测量特性,避免因高危高估导致过度治疗。
局限性
- 原文摘要未报告研究局限性信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the CAMBRA caries risk assessment tool (CRAT) in terms of its measurement properties: reliability, validity and responsiveness to change in caries estimates over time. METHODS: Secondary data from the VicGeneration (VicGen) birth cohort study were used. Caries risk status at child age18 months was compared against caries development at 36 and 48 months. Questionnaire data for the 18-month-old children, were used to generate the CRAT item responses. Five examiners assessed the caries risk profile for each 18-month-old child and assigned a risk status. The analytic method was informed by the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments Checklist. RESULTS: Each examiner applied the CAMBRA CRAT to 214 cases from the VicGen study. At 18 months of age, the proportion of low-, moderate- and high-risk children were 17 %, 17 % and 66 %, respectively. Caries prevalence at 36 and 48 months of age was 18 % and 35 %, respectively. Almost perfect reliability (both inter- and intra-reliability) was achieved in caries risk categorisation. For criterion validity and responsiveness, the area under the curve was approximately 0.50. For the dichotomised risk, the sensitivity of the CAMBRA CRAT to predict caries at 36 and 48 months, was 74 % and 70 %, respectively. The corresponding specificity scores were 35 % and 36 %, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The results from this study show that the CAMBRA CRAT, in its current form, is not a good predictor of future caries among young Victorian children and in fact overestimates the proportion of children at high-risk of future disease. As such, it may not be ideal for use among young Victorian children and it is highly likely it's use could be driving over treatment. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This study provides evidence for the applicability of the CAMBRA CRAT with young Victorian children to inform decision making on caries risk-based management. It also highlights the important measurement properties and related analytics (applicable to any CRAT) that should be considered when selecting a CRAT for use in clinical practice.
引用
- Christian B, Calache H, Adams G, et al. A methodological study to assess the measurement properties (reliability and validity) of a caries risk assessment tool for young children. J Dent. 2020. PMID: 32200008. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103324
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。