模块化3D打印模型在牙体牙髓本科教学中的认知评价
研究将含离体牙与电子工作长度测定的模块化3D打印模型用于68名本科生牙髓教学,每人在离体牙上完成完整根管治疗。87%学生认为该模型比传统台式模型更难,但96%认为更好准备临床、93%建议未来用于临床前培训;根尖定位仪预判工作长度在85%病例中与影像学接受范围一致。
要点
- 模块化3D打印模型含离体牙与电子工作长度测定,可置入仿真头模。
- 87%学生认为该模型比传统台式模型明显更难,96%认为更好准备临床。
- 93%学生建议未来临床前牙髓培训使用该模型,92%报告后续临床压力降低。
核心结论
- 绝大多数学生虽认为模块化3D打印模型更难,但仍给予正面评价并建议用于临床前教学。
- 该模型可更真实模拟临床情境并同步使用根尖定位仪,降低后续临床牙髓治疗压力。
研究设计与样本
- 将人颅骨锥形束体层摄影数据转为STL数据,制作含可独立拆卸六分区与牙齿的模块化3D打印模型。
- 68名本科生在离体牙上完成完整根管治疗,用根尖定位仪与影像学确定工作长度,并以卡方检验分析一致性。
主要发现
- 共治疗68颗牙(20颗切牙、26颗前磨牙、22颗磨牙)的127个根管。
- 87%学生认为模块化3D打印模型比传统台式模型明显更难,96%认为更好准备临床,92%报告后续临床牙髓练习压力明显降低,93%建议未来使用。
- 根尖定位仪预判后85%病例工作长度在距影像根尖0-2 mm可接受范围。
- 读数距根尖超过2 mm或超出根尖在磨牙中显著多于前磨牙和切牙(P < 0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 可在临床前牙髓教学中引入含离体牙与电子工作长度测定的模块化3D打印模型,以提升临床情境模拟度。
- 教学使用时应预期学生感知难度高于传统台式模型,并关注磨牙工作长度测定偏差风险。
局限性
- 研究仅基于学生主观评价与工作长度一致性分析,未报告客观操作表现或临床结局。
- 样本为68名本科生与68颗离体牙,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate a modular 3D print training dental model with embedded human teeth and electronic working length determination for undergraduate endodontic education. METHODOLOGY: Cone-beam volume tomography data of a human skull were transferred into stereolithographic (STL) data, and a customizable modular 3D print model with individually removable sextants and teeth was generated for the use in commercially available phantom heads. Each of sixty-eight students performed a complete root canal treatment on an extracted human tooth. Working lengths were determined with electronic apex locators (EAL) and verified radiographically. Subsequently, an evaluation was carried out with regard to the difficulty of the working steps access cavity preparation, working length determination, root canal preparation/irrigation and canal filling, and these steps were compared to commonly used benchtop models. Additionally, the agreement of electronic and radiographic working length determination was assessed and analysed statistically with the chi-square test. RESULTS: A total of 68 teeth (20 incisors, 26 premolars and 22 molars) with 127 root canals were treated. In total, 87% of the students considered the modular 3D print model considerably more demanding than the conventional benchtop model. Overall, 96% felt better prepared for the clinical situation, 92% felt markedly reduced stress levels during endodontic practice in the subsequent clinical courses, and 93% of the students suggested the model should be used in future preclinical endodontic training. The preradiographic use of EAL resulted in 85% of the cases having radiographically acceptable working length determination within 0-2 mm from the radiographic apex. Readings more than 2 mm from the apex or beyond were significantly more common in molars than in premolars and incisors (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The vast majority of students rated the modular 3D print training model positively despite it being more demanding. They also recommended its use in preclinical teaching and training. The model allowed a more realistic simulation of the clinical situation with a simultaneous use of EALs and led to reduced stress levels in endodontic treatment in the subsequent clinical courses.
引用
- Hanafi A, Donnermeyer D, Schäfer E, et al. Perception of a modular 3D print model in undergraduate endodontic education. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 32220071. doi:10.1111/iej.13299
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。