文献速递口腔修复与种植牙周病

引导骨再生与结缔组织移植重建颊侧凸度的随机对照研究:一年美学与患者报告结局

A randomized controlled study comparing guided bone regeneration with connective tissue graft to re-establish buccal convexity: One-year aesthetic and patient-reported outcomes.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Oral Implants Res · 2020-02-21

一年后两组PES无显著差异,但CTG组MSI显著低于GBR组,GBR组术后水肿、血肿及止痛药使用更多。

要点

  • GBR与CTG均可获得良好的专业与患者美学评价,PES无显著差异。
  • CTG组黏膜瘢痕指数显著低于GBR组,瘢痕更轻。
  • GBR组术后水肿、血肿及止痛药需求更高。

核心结论

  • GBR与CTG均能获得专业人员和患者认可的良好美学效果。
  • GBR因需附加垂直和骨膜切口,导致更多瘢痕、术后不适和止痛药需求。

研究设计与样本

  • 单盲随机对照试验,上前牙单牙缺失伴水平牙槽骨缺损患者。
  • 所有位点颊腭向骨宽度至少6 mm,植入单颗种植体后随机分配至GBR或CTG组重建颊侧软组织凸度。

主要发现

  • PES组间无显著差异(GBR:10.11;CTG:10.48;p=.577)。
  • MSI在CTG组(1.10)显著低于GBR组(2.53)(p=.017)。
  • GBR组瘢痕更宽、颜色不匹配更多、缝线痕迹略多,但患者认为不困扰,软组织美学VAS相似(GBR:84;CTG:87)。
  • GBR组至少两个术后时间点水肿和血肿评分是CTG组的两倍,止痛药使用更多(7.10 vs 4.86)。
  • 两组OHIP-14从基线至1年随访均下降,提示日常生活不适减少。

关键数值与推荐

  • 颊腭向骨宽度至少6 mm为纳入标准。
  • 主要结局为1年后PES和MSI,次要结局为术后早期及1年PROMs。

临床怎么用

  • 上前牙单牙缺失伴水平骨缺损需重建颊侧凸度时,GBR与CTG均可获得良好美学效果。
  • 若关注术后瘢痕和早期不适,可优先考虑CTG;选择GBR时应预期更多瘢痕和止痛药需求。

局限性

  • 组间MSI和PROMs差异可能归因于GBR需垂直释放切口、骨膜切口及可能引起炎症的生物材料。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To compare guided bone regeneration (GBR) with connective tissue graft (CTG) in terms of aesthetic and patient-reported outcomes (PROMs). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients with a single tooth gap in the anterior maxilla and horizontal alveolar defect were enrolled in a single-blind RCT. All sites had a buccopalatal bone dimension of at least 6 mm, received a single implant and were randomly allocated to the control (GBR) or test group (CTG) to re-establish buccal soft tissue convexity. Primary outcomes were Pink Esthetic Score (PES) and Mucosal Scarring Index (MSI) assessed after 1 year. Secondary outcomes included PROMs registered during the early stages of healing and after 1 year. RESULTS: Twenty-one patients were included per group (control: 11 females, mean age 51; test: nine females, mean age 48). Although there was no significant difference in the PES between the groups (control: 10.11; test: 10.48; p = .577), the MSI was significantly lower in the test (1.10) than in the control group (2.53) (p = .017). Based on descriptive statistics, the latter demonstrated wider scars, more colour mismatch and slightly more suture marks. However, these were not considered disturbing by the patients given similar VAS on soft tissue aesthetics (control: 84; test: 87). Oedema and haematoma were rated twice as high in the control group on at least two postoperative time points, and patients took more painkillers (7.10 vs. 4.86). OHIP-14 decreased in both groups between baseline and 1-year follow-up, indicative of less discomfort in daily life. Differences in MSI and PROMs between the groups may be explained by the need of a vertical releasing incision in order to achieve sufficient access for GBR, periosteal incisions and the use of biomaterials that may induce inflammation. CONCLUSION: GBR and CTG resulted in favourable aesthetic outcomes as assessed by professionals and patients. However, given additional vertical and periosteal incisions, GBR resulted in more scarring, postoperative discomfort and a higher need for painkillers.

来源:Clin Oral Implants Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. De Bruyckere T, Cosyn J, Younes F, et al. A randomized controlled study comparing guided bone regeneration with connective tissue graft to re-establish buccal convexity: One-year aesthetic and patient-reported outcomes. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2020. PMID: 32011032. doi:10.1111/clr.13587

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。