愿望满足医学与愿望满足牙科
本文阐述愿望满足医学的概念及其与牙科的关系,指出其由专业人员使用医学方法满足患者非医学愿望,涉及美容牙科、修复和正畸等领域,可能带来伦理与法律问题,需牙医批判性反思临床决策。
要点
- 愿望满足牙科指使用医学方法满足非医学愿望,常见于美容、修复和正畸。
- 非医学必要的治疗可能有害,且可能挤占有限医疗资源。
- 伦理与法律可指导牙医反思愿望满足牙科的临床决策。
核心结论
- 对愿望满足医学及其伦理法律主题的一般理解与牙科相关。
研究设计与样本
- 通过Pubmed和Google Scholar识别相关论文和权威机构报告。
主要发现
- 愿望满足医学指专业人员使用医学方法在医疗环境中满足患者非医学愿望。
- 医疗提供者、医疗行业和健康保险公司也促成医学和牙科中的愿望满足。
- 健康与疾病概念模糊及边界不清为愿望满足医学提供不稳定基础。
- 在医疗资源有限时,对这类服务需求增长可能取代医学必要治疗。
- 无医学或牙科必要性的治疗可能有害,并带来无效或过度治疗风险。
关键数值与推荐
- 牙科例子见于美容干预、修复和正畸领域,对正常小偏差的感知引发干预愿望或建议。
临床怎么用
- 伦理考虑和立法可指导牙医批判性反思愿望满足牙科的临床决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: to explain the practice of wish-fulfilling medicine and how it relates to dentistry. SOURCES: Relevant papers, and reports from authoritative institutions were identified in Pubmed and Google Scholar. RESULTS: Wish-fulfilling medicine refers to services provided by professionals using medical methods in a medical setting to address non-medical wishes of patients. Care-providers, medical industries, and health-insurance companies also contribute to wish-fulfilling in medicine and dentistry. Various concepts of health and illness compounded by blurred borders between health and illness offer an unstable foundation for wish-fulfilling medicine, and growing demands for these services where healthcare resources are limited can displace medically necessary treatments. Moreover, treatments without a medical or a dental necessity, can be harmful and bear the risk of futile or excessive treatments not in patients' long-term interest. Examples in dentistry are found in the field of cosmetic interventions, prosthodontics and orthodontics, where perceptions of small 'deviations' from normality prompt wishes or recommendations for intervention. Ethically, wish-fulfilling services confront the principles of the common morality if the autonomy of a patient is compromised, beneficence is unclear, harm is foreseeable, or distributive justice is compromised. Wish-fulfilling dental treatment can be restricted by legislation if it conflicts with safe, effective and efficient care, or if it interferes with patient's real needs or undermines established professional standards. CONCLUSIONS: The general understanding of wish-fulfilling medicine including its ethical and legal themes is relevant to dentistry. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Ethical considerations and legislation can guide a dentist to reflect critically on clinical decisions regarding wish-fulfilling dentistry.
引用
- Witter DJ, Kole JJJ, Brands WG, et al. Wish-fulfilling medicine and wish-fulfilling dentistry. J Dent. 2020. PMID: 32087260. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2020.103302
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。