可可碱对牙釉质龋损体外脱矿与再矿化的影响
这项体外研究在菌斑液样条件下,将272个牛牙釉质标本制成早期龋损,按氟浓度(0.2或1 ppm)、可可碱浓度(0、10、100或200 ppm)和pH(5.5或7.0)析因设计分组,观察再脱矿后表面显微硬度恢复百分比。结果显示可可碱在各浓度下均不影响再矿化,氟与pH存在显著交互作用,可可碱不能推荐为防龋剂。
要点
- 可可碱在0、10、100、200 ppm浓度下均不影响牙釉质龋损的脱矿或再矿化。
- 氟浓度与pH存在显著交互作用(p=0.030),可可碱与二者无显著交互。
- 基于现有证据,可可碱不能推荐作为防龋剂。
核心结论
- 在菌斑液样介质中持续存在时,可可碱在所测浓度和pH条件下不影响牙釉质龋损的脱矿或再矿化。
- 基于现有证据,可可碱不能推荐作为防龋剂。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,使用272个牛牙釉质标本制作早期龋损,按Knoop表面显微硬度(SMH)分组。
- 析因设计:氟浓度0.2或1 ppm、可可碱浓度0、10、100或200 ppm、pH 5.5或7.0,共十六组,每组n=17。
主要发现
- 三因素交互作用不显著(p=0.712)。
- 氟与pH的交互作用显著(p=0.030),氟与可可碱(p=0.478)及pH与可可碱(p=0.998)的交互作用不显著。
- 可可碱在所有测试浓度下均不影响%SMHr。
- 0.2 ppm氟在pH 5.5时的再硬化显著少于0.2 ppm氟在pH 7.0时以及1 ppm氟在pH 5.5时。
临床怎么用
- 基于现有体外证据,不建议将可可碱作为防龋活性成分用于临床或产品开发。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This in vitro study investigated the effect of theobromine on the de- and remineralization of enamel carious lesions under plaque fluid-like conditions. METHODS: Early carious lesions were created in 272 bovine enamel specimens and assigned to sixteen groups (n=17) based on Knoop surface microhardness (SMH). Lesions were demineralized again under plaque fluid-like conditions in the presence of fluoride (0.2 or 1ppm) and theobromine (0; 10; 100 or 200ppm) at different pH values (5.5 or 7.0) in a factorial design. SMH was determined again and percent SMH recovery (%SMHr) calculated. Three-way ANOVA was used for the fixed effects of fluoride, theobromine and pH levels to compare the differences between each level. RESULTS: The three-way interaction was not significant (p=0.712). The two-way interaction between fluoride and pH was significant (p=0.030), whereas those between fluoride and theobromine as well as that for pH and theobromine were not (p=0.478 and p=0.998, respectively). Theobromine did not affect %SMHr at any of the tested concentrations. There were trends for the higher fluoride concentration and the higher pH resulting in more rehardening with the lesions exposed to 0.2ppm fluoride at pH 5.5 displaying significantly less rehardening than those exposed to 0.2ppm fluoride at pH of 7.0 and lesions exposed to 1ppm fluoride at pH of 5.5. CONCLUSION: Theobromine, when continuously present in a plaque fluid-like medium at various concentrations and at different pH values, does not affect de- or remineralization of enamel carious lesions under the presently studied conditions. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Based on the presently available evidence, theobromine cannot be recommended as an anticaries agent.
引用
- Thorn AK, Lin WS, Levon JA, et al. The effect of theobromine on the in vitro de- and remineralization of enamel carious lesions. J Dent. 2020. PMID: 34059300. doi:10.1016/j.jjodo.2020.100013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。