根分叉缺损再生手术治疗:系统综述与贝叶斯网络荟萃分析
本系统综述与贝叶斯网络荟萃分析纳入20项随机对照试验(575例患者/787个缺损),比较再生手术与开瓣清创术(OFD)治疗根分叉缺损的疗效。结果显示再生技术优于OFD,根分叉改善OR=20.9(90% CrI=5.81,69.41),水平骨增益1.6mm、垂直附着增益1.3mm、探诊深度减少1.3mm。骨替代移植物(BRG)在水平骨增益中排名最佳(Pr=61%)。
要点
- 再生手术在根分叉改善、骨增益和探诊深度减少上均优于OFD。
- 根分叉闭合率0%-60%,I度转化率29%-100%。
- 含骨替代移植物的方案临床性能更高。
核心结论
- II度根分叉缺损的再生手术优于开瓣清创术,多数缺损可实现根分叉闭合或I度转化。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索随机对照试验,随访至少12个月,共纳入20项RCT(19项II度,1项III度),575例患者/787个缺损。
主要发现
- 再生技术对比OFD的根分叉改善OR=20.9(90% CrI=5.81,69.41),水平临床附着增益1.6mm,垂直临床附着增益1.3mm,探诊深度减少1.3mm。
- 根分叉闭合率范围为0%至60%(10项试验),I度转化率范围为29%至100%(6项试验)。
- 骨替代移植物在水平骨增益中成为最佳治疗的概率最高(Pr=61%)。
- 非吸收性膜+骨替代移植物在垂直临床附着增益(Pr=75%)和探诊深度减少(Pr=56%)中排名最佳。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐对II度根分叉缺损采用再生手术治疗而非单纯OFD。
- 含骨替代移植物的再生方案可能获得更好的临床效果。
临床怎么用
- 临床治疗II度根分叉缺损可优先考虑再生手术,尤其是含骨替代移植物的方案。
- 预期多数缺损可实现根分叉闭合或I度转化,但需结合个体情况评估。
局限性
- 纳入研究中仅1项为III度根分叉缺损,结论主要适用于II度。
- 未报告牙齿丧失数据,无法评估长期存留率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To investigate the clinical performance of regenerative periodontal surgery in the treatment of furcation defects versus open flap debridement (OFD) and to compare different regenerative modalities. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A systematic search was conducted to identify RCTs evaluating regenerative surgical treatment of furcations with a minimum of 12-month follow-up. Three authors independently reviewed, selected and extracted data from the search conducted and assessed risk of bias. Primary outcomes were tooth loss, furcation improvement (closure/conversion) (FImp), gain of horizontal bone level (HBL) and attachment level (HCAL). Secondary outcomes were gain in vertical attachment level (VCAL), probing pocket depth (PPD) reduction, PROMs and adverse events. Data were summarized into Bayesian standard and network meta-analysis in order to estimate direct and indirect treatment effects and to establish a ranking of treatments. RESULTS: The search identified 19 articles, reporting on 20 RCTs (19 on class II, 1 on class III furcations) with a total of 575 patients/787 defects. Tooth loss was not reported. Furcation closure ranged between 0% and 60% (10 trials), and class I conversion from 29% to 100% (six trials). Regenerative techniques were superior to OFD for FImp (OR = 20.9; 90% CrI = 5.81, 69.41), HCAL gain (1.6 mm), VCAL gain (1.3 mm) and PPD reduction (1.3 mm). Bone replacement grafts (BRG) resulted in the highest probability (Pr = 61%) of being the best treatment for HBL gain. Non-resorbable membranes + BRG ranked as the best treatment for VCAL gain (Pr = 75%) and PPD reduction (Pr = 56%). CONCLUSIONS: Regenerative surgery of class II furcations is superior to OFD. FImp (furcation closure or class I conversion) can be expected for the majority of defects. Treatment modalities involving BRG are associated with higher performance.
引用
- Jepsen S, Gennai S, Hirschfeld J, et al. Regenerative surgical treatment of furcation defects: A systematic review and Bayesian network meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. J Clin Periodontol. 2020. PMID: 31860125. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13238
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。