辅助激光或抗菌光动力治疗在未治疗牙周炎非手术机械治疗中的系统评价与荟萃分析
该系统评价与荟萃分析比较了在未治疗牙周炎患者中,辅助使用激光或抗菌光动力治疗(aPDT)与单独非手术机械治疗的疗效。共纳入10篇激光辅助治疗和8篇aPDT辅助治疗文献。针对aPDT的荟萃分析(2篇,n=42)未发现辅助aPDT在探诊深度改善上有统计学显著差异(WMD=0.35 mm;95%CI:-0.04/0.73;p=.08)。辅助激光的临床结果6个月时变异性高,患者报告获益尚待证实。
要点
- 辅助aPDT(波长650-700 nm)在探诊深度改善上未显示统计学显著优势。
- 辅助激光治疗6个月临床结果变异性高,证据有限。
- 患者报告获益尚待证实,需更多高质量对照研究。
核心结论
- 辅助激光或aPDT治疗未治疗牙周炎的现有证据受限于对照研究数量少和研究设计异质性。
- 患者报告获益尚待证实。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与荟萃分析,纳入随机对照临床试验(RCT)和对照临床试验(CCT)。
- 共纳入10篇辅助激光治疗和8篇辅助aPDT治疗文献。
主要发现
- 针对aPDT的荟萃分析包括2篇文献(总n=42;裂口设计),未发现辅助aPDT在探诊深度变化上有统计学显著差异(WMD=0.35 mm;95%CI:-0.04/0.73;p=.08)。
- 辅助激光治疗6个月临床结果变异性高。
- 2篇文献报告患者报告结局,10篇报告 harms/adverse effects 的有无。
局限性
- 对照研究数量少。
- 研究设计异质性高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare the adjunctive effects of lasers or antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) to non-surgical mechanical instrumentation alone in untreated periodontitis patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two focused questions were addressed using the Population, Intervention, Comparison and Outcome criteria as follows: in patients with untreated periodontitis, (a) does laser application provide adjunctive effects on probing pocket depth (PPD) changes compared with non-surgical instrumentation alone? and (b) does application of aPDT provide adjunctive effects on PPD changes compared with non-surgical instrumentation alone? Both randomized controlled clinical trials (RCTs) and controlled clinical trials (CCTs) were included. Results of the meta-analysis are expressed as weighted mean differences (WMD) and reported according to the PRISMA guidelines. RESULTS: Out of 1,202 records, 10 articles for adjunctive laser and 8 for adjunctive aPDT were included. With respect to PPD changes, 1 meta-analysis including 2 articles (total n = 42; split-mouth design) failed to identify a statistically significant difference (WMD = 0.35 mm; 95%CI: -0.04/0.73; p = .08) in favour of adjunctive aPDT (wavelength range 650-700 nm). In terms of adjunctive laser application, a high variability of clinical outcomes at 6 months was noted. Two articles included patient-reported outcomes and 10 reported on the presence/absence of harms/adverse effects. CONCLUSIONS: Available evidence on adjunctive therapy with lasers and aPDT is limited by (a) the low number of controlled studies and (b) the heterogeneity of study designs. Patient-reported benefits remain to be demonstrated.
引用
- Salvi GE, Stähli A, Schmidt JC, et al. Adjunctive laser or antimicrobial photodynamic therapy to non-surgical mechanical instrumentation in patients with untreated periodontitis: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Periodontol. 2020. PMID: 31859395. doi:10.1111/jcpe.13236
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。