负压与正压冲洗在椭圆形根管根尖分支中的计算流体力学评价
本研究利用微CT扫描下颌磨牙椭圆形根管根尖分支建立计算流体力学模型,比较负压冲洗(MiC)与正压冲洗配合三种针头(侧方开口SV、前方开口FV、缺口N)在不同插入深度下的流型、流速、根尖压力和剪切应力。结果显示针头插入深度显著影响剪切应力和根尖压力,SV针头兼具较低正压和较高剪切应力,N针头剪切应力最低,FV根尖压力最高,MiC在部分根尖分支产生负根尖压力但剪切应力和流速较低。
要点
- 针头插入深度显著影响根尖剪切应力和压力,距工作长度1 mm时剪切应力、流速和根尖压力最高。
- 侧方开口针头兼具较低正压和较高剪切应力,根尖压力低于挤出风险阈值。
- 负压冲洗可在部分根尖分支产生负根尖压力,但剪切应力和流速较低。
核心结论
- 侧方开口针头表现出较低正压与较高剪切应力的组合,缺口针头剪切应力最低,前方开口针头根尖压力最高。
- 负压冲洗可在部分根尖分支产生负根尖压力,但剪切应力和流速较低。
研究设计与样本
- 采用微CT扫描下颌磨牙椭圆形根管根尖分支进行几何重建,并运用计算流体力学模拟比较不同冲洗方案。
- 模拟中针头置于距工作长度1 mm和3 mm两个位置。
主要发现
- 针头插入深度对剪切应力和根尖压力有强烈影响,三种针头在距工作长度1 mm时剪切应力、流速和根尖压力最高,并产生中等流速。
- 缺口针头模拟中流体未到达根尖分支,正压针头中剪切应力值最低。
- 前方开口针头以轴向分量为主,呈现不同冲洗模式,剪切应力值高且根尖压力高于其他针头。
- 侧方开口针头模拟中流体在大部分主根管中分布广泛,剪切应力值最高,根尖压力低于挤出风险阈值。
- 负压冲洗与低流速、低剪切应力和低根尖压力相关。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择冲洗针头时需考虑插入深度对根尖压力和剪切应力的影响,避免过深插入增加根尖压力风险。
- 侧方开口针头可能提供较好的剪切应力同时保持较低根尖压力,适用于需要兼顾冲洗效果与安全性的场景。
- 负压冲洗在根尖分支中产生的剪切应力和流速较低,可能影响冲洗清洁效率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) the flow pattern, irrigant velocity, apical pressure and shear stress produced by negative (MiC) and positive pressure with different types of needles (side-vented (SV), front-vented (FV) and notched (N)) at two insertion depths in the apical ramification of oval root canals. METHODOLOGY: The micro-CT of a mandibular molar with an oval root canal with an apical ramification was used for computational analysis after preparation and geometric reconstruction. Geometries with the needles in two positions (1 and 3 mm from WL) were created to run the simulations. Key parameters of irrigation were displayed with CFD and compared. RESULTS: The penetration depth of the needle in the root canal strongly influenced shear stress and apical pressure. The three needles revealed that the highest shear stress, velocity and apical pressure were 1 mm from the WL and generated medium velocities. In N simulations, the fluid flow did not reach the apical ramification and the lowest shear stress values for positive pressure needles were found. The predominant axial component for FV revealed a different pattern of irrigation with high shear stress values and higher apical pressures than those exerted by other needles. SV simulations had generalized fluid flow in most of the main canal, the highest shear stress values and lower apical pressure than the threshold determined for risk of extrusion. MiC was associated with low velocity, shear stress and apical pressure. CONCLUSION: The SV needle demonstrated a combination of low positive pressure and high shear stress; while N had the lowest shear stress and FV the highest apical pressure. MiC generated fluid flow in part of the apical ramification with negative apical pressure values but low shear stress and velocity.
引用
- Loroño G, Zaldivar JR, Arias A, et al. Positive and negative pressure irrigation in oval root canals with apical ramifications: a computational fluid dynamics evaluation in micro-CT scanned real teeth. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 31814134. doi:10.1111/iej.13260
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。