不同牙体模型在牙髓培训中的适用性:研究生操作表现与常见错误检测
本研究比较五种上颌第一磨牙人工模型用于牙髓治疗培训时学生的感受与操作表现,十名研究生在每种模型上完成根管治疗并填写满意度问卷,三名资深牙髓病教育家评分并检测常见错误。结果显示评估者间信度很高(ICCC=0.939,ICCA=0.940),学生在不同模型上表现有显著差异(P<0.05),60%学生偏好DRSK模型,70%对TrueTooth评价最低,评估者更偏好基于天然牙microCT扫描制作的模型。
要点
- 评估者间信度很高:一致性ICCC=0.939,绝对一致性ICCA=0.940。
- 学生在不同牙体模型上操作表现存在显著差异(P<0.05)。
- 60%学生偏好DRSK模型,70%对TrueTooth评价最低。
核心结论
- 基于天然牙microCT扫描制作的模型(TrueTooth和DENTALIKE)在评估者中接受度更好。
- 学生在TrueTooth模型上评分和表现较差,因其难度更高。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用五组(每组n=10)人工上颌第一磨牙模型:DEPT、DRSK、Nissin、DENTALIKE和TrueTooth。
- 十名研究生在五种模型上按随机顺序各完成一次根管治疗并填写满意度问卷。
- 三名培训并校准的牙髓病教育家(均超过15年经验)使用评分量表评估操作并填写问卷以检测特定模型相关的常见错误。
主要发现
- 评估者间信度很高:一致性ICCC=0.939(95%CI 0.902-0.964),绝对一致性ICCA=0.940(95%CI 0.904-0.965)。
- 评估者评分间无显著差异,但学生在不同牙体模型上表现不同(P<0.05)。
- 60%学生偏好DRSK模型用于根管治疗培训,其次是DENTALIKE(30%)。
- 70%学生对TrueTooth评价最低,原因包括解剖结构复杂和对器械及热牙胶充填器抵抗力差。
- 评估者检测到特定牙体模型中的若干常见错误,并偏好基于天然牙microCT扫描制作的模型。
临床怎么用
- 牙髓培训中可优先考虑基于天然牙microCT扫描制作的模型,因其评估者接受度更高。
- 选择模型时需权衡学生偏好与操作难度,DRSK学生偏好度高,TrueTooth难度较高。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare the perceptions of students when using five different tooth replicas and to detect common errors in the performance of students that might be attributed to a specific type of tooth replica. METHODOLOGY: Five groups (n = 10 each) of artificial first maxillary molars (DEPT, DRSK, Nissin, DENTALIKE and TrueTooth) were used. All 50 teeth were mounted individually in opaque containers, distributed in 10 packages containing a sample from each with an assigned random order for students to perform root canal treatments. Ten postgraduate students each performed a root canal treatment on the five replicas, in the assigned order, and completed a satisfaction questionnaire. Three trained and calibrated endodontic educators, each with more than 15 years of experience, evaluated their performance using a grading rubric and completed a questionnaire to detect common errors attributed to a specific tooth replica. Inter-rater reliability was calculated with the interclass correlation coefficient for both consistency and absolute agreement. A two-way related measures anova was used to assess the interaction amongst evaluators and tooth groups on the average scores of students. Post hoc T3 Dunnet was used to compare groups. The perceptions of students amongst groups were compared with chi-square and linear-by-linear association tests. RESULTS: Inter-rater reliability was very high for both consistency (ICCC = 0.939; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.902-0.964) and absolute agreement (ICCA = 0.940; 95% CI 0.904-0.965). No significant differences were found amongst the ratings of evaluators; however, students performed differently when using the various tooth replicas (P < 0.05). Overall, 60% of students preferred the DRSK replica for root canal treatment training purposes, followed by DENTALIKE (30%). The least preferred was TrueTooth (70% responses) due to its complex anatomy and poor resistance to instruments and heat pluggers. Evaluators detected several common errors in specific tooth replicas and preferred tooth replicas manufactured based on microCT scans of natural teeth. CONCLUSIONS: Tooth replicas manufactured based on microCT scans of natural teeth (TrueTooth and DENTALIKE) had much better acceptance amongst evaluators, although students rated and performed less well in TrueTooth replicas due to their greater level of difficulty.
引用
- Gancedo-Caravia L, Bascones J, García-Barbero E, et al. Suitability of different tooth replicas for endodontic training: perceptions and detection of common errors in the performance of postgraduate students. Int Endod J. 2019. PMID: 31721237. doi:10.1111/iej.13251
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。