牙科随机对照试验摘要中的「spin」:横断面分析
该横断面分析基于Eigenfactor评分在排名前10的牙科期刊中系统检索2015年发表、主要结局无统计学意义的随机对照试验(RCT),共纳入75项RCT,评估3类spin(摘要中对结果的歪曲表述)的出现情况及其影响因素。结果显示23篇摘要(30.7%)存在spin,国际协作、商业支持类型、治疗组数量和期刊影响因子与spin的关联均无统计学意义(P ≥ .05)。作者提示临床医生应警惕摘要中的spin,应用其推荐前应阅读并评价完整试验。
要点
- 约30.7%的RCT摘要在主要结局无统计学意义时仍存在spin。
- 国际协作、商业支持类型、治疗组数量、期刊影响因子与spin无显著关联(P ≥ .05)。
- 临床决策前应阅读完整试验而非仅依赖摘要。
核心结论
- 在2015年高影响力牙科期刊发表的75项主要结局无统计学意义的RCT中,约三分之一摘要存在某种形式的spin,且与资助类型和期刊影响因子无关。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面分析:基于Eigenfactor评分系统检索排名前10的牙科期刊,纳入2015年发表、主要结局无统计学意义的RCT,共75项;涵盖综合牙科、牙科研究、口腔种植、牙体牙髓、口腔外科、牙周和口腔肿瘤等学科;采用t检验和χ2检验分析影响因素。
主要发现
- 75项RCT中23篇摘要(30.7%)存在spin。
- 国际协作、商业支持类型、治疗组数量和期刊影响因子与摘要spin的关联均无统计学意义(P ≥ .05)。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应意识到摘要中可能存在spin,在将试验推荐用于临床实践前应认真阅读和评价完整试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Spin in randomized controlled trial (RCT) abstracts can misguide clinicians. In this cross-sectional analysis, the authors assessed the prevalence of spin in RCT abstracts and explored the factors potentially influencing it. METHODS: In this cross-sectional analysis, the authors conducted a systematic search in top 10 dental journals based on Eigenfactor score and selected RCTs published in 2015 with statistically nonsignificant primary outcomes. The dentistry disciplines covered in these journals include general dentistry, dental research, oral implantology, endodontics, oral surgery, periodontology, and oral oncology. In these RCT abstracts, the authors assessed the prevalence of 3 different categories of spin and factors that could influence its presence using the t test and χ2 test. RESULTS: Spin assessment performed in the included 75 RCTs revealed the existence of spin in 23 abstracts (30.7%). Associations between the presence of spin in abstracts and the variables international collaborations, commercial support type, number of treatment arms, and journal impact factor were found to be statistically nonsignificant (P ≥ .05). CONCLUSIONS: Approximately one-third of the 75 RCT abstracts published in high-impact dental journals in 2015 with nonsignificant outcomes presented with some form of spin, irrespective of funding type and journal impact factor. PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: Clinicians should be aware of the potential existence of spin in abstracts and be diligent in reading and appraising the full trial before incorporating its recommendations in clinical practice.
引用
- Roszhart JI, Kumar SS, Allareddy V, et al. Spin in abstracts of randomized controlled trials in dentistry: A cross-sectional analysis. J Am Dent Assoc. 2019. PMID: 31748148. doi:10.1016/j.adaj.2019.08.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。